Is monogamy naive?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • indian_blues
    replied
    Originally posted by maryam_shirazi_9 View Post
    happens everywhere,
    Not Really.

    Originally posted by maryam_shirazi_9 View Post
    You even get adverts at backs of newspapers etc.
    Ridiculous.

    Originally posted by maryam_shirazi_9 View Post
    People in the West are more open when talking about these things, but just because they dont talk about this in the East, doesnt mean it doesnt happen.
    I find it totally against the human nature. No you can never find these types of relationship anywhere in eastern societies. It's morally wrong.

    btw the girl in ur avatar is cute.

    Leave a comment:


  • maryam9
    replied
    Originally posted by indian_blues
    I heard that Germans share their partners with their friends for a short term (for sexual purpose). I'm not sure where in Germany and I cannot confirm this but I read it somewhere. Y I'm saying is it would be possible for short term.
    happens everywhere, not just in Germany. You even get adverts at backs of newspapers etc. Just watch a few Jerry Springer episodes and youll know what i mean! (dont know if u get that show over there in india, though).

    People in the West are more open when talking about these things, but just because they dont talk about this in the East, doesnt mean it doesnt happen.

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by indian_blues View Post
    What about the concept of having concubines in Iranian society?
    India, what I'm saying is that Iranian men and women have a different mental framework on this issue than Indians. I even think Westerners are different in this respect than Indians.

    My hypothesis is that Indians realize the unrealistic restrictions of immature partnerships, and are thus more tolerant. I feel that in Iranian and Western culture, there is a push towards not having immature partnerships to begin with, and that being with someone else when you're in a relationship, unless with explicit agreement, is always wrong.

    I personally think that if this difference is true, it is complementary.

    Leave a comment:


  • indian_blues
    replied
    What about the concept of having concubines in Iranian society?

    Leave a comment:


  • indian_blues
    replied
    Exactly. Not only India but all strong cultural oriented societies.

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by indian_blues View Post
    I go with ur latter part. I think its kinda natural.
    Yes, but I think this may be limited to Indian culture right now.

    Leave a comment:


  • indian_blues
    replied
    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    So the girl doesn't "know" and is therefore naive? Or does she subconsciously know that her partner is with others, or suspects, and doesn't care?
    I go with ur latter part. I think its kinda natural.

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by indian_blues View Post
    I think males do prefer multiple partners becoz of their natural characteristics and i think they wish to have it secretly not damaging the relationship with their primary partner, coz as she was the backbone for his family. The illegal relationship must be ending abruptly coz it was just started to satisfy their short term needs.
    So the girl doesn't "know" and is therefore naive? Or does she subconsciously know that her partner is with others, or suspects, and doesn't care?

    Leave a comment:


  • indian_blues
    replied
    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    Really, what makes you think that?

    And, even if males have more of these things, it doesn't mean that they have more of a preference for different partners. Or does it?
    Reason Male are stronger sex. They have the free will to do than females. Sex becomes a basic need after a person attends an age. Humans do have desire to taste different foods. . "Basically Humans are Animals", let us honor the quote.

    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    Would it be better if both in the relationship agreed instead of either making it a secret?
    No it makes the case worse. It is against the ethics. Most of the religion and all culture preaches "One Woman for One man", yes exceptions exists. No men or women wants their partner to have a serious relationship with someone, for women it threatens her security and survival and for men its a matter of sexual morals. Well maybe they could agree on satisfying their sexual desires but i would say no one would want to share their partner with other as a long term relationship.

    I heard that Germans share their partners with their friends for a short term (for sexual purpose). I'm not sure where in Germany and I cannot confirm this but I read it somewhere. Y I'm saying is it would be possible for short term.

    Personally Adulteration is wrong.

    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    Is it possible and desirable to satisfy your sexual urges before having a serious relationship?
    Personally I won't. I think these desires should be satisfied with the righteous person.
    Last edited by indian_blues; 07-18-2007, 01:06 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by maryam_shirazi_9 View Post
    here are my replies - and yeah, there are a lot of grey areas, and im no psychologist. I can see what you're saying aswell.


    What im saying is that they *must* see it as abuse, because of many things such as
    -sudden change in tone of victims partner
    -change in facial expression of victim
    etc
    this is where i said this -

    i read your reply and i do agree that some people may distort things in their head

    ~~~


    Literal translation - when offering a person a seat, you can either say
    "please, take a seat"
    "sit down", or
    "sit the hell down", but they all have the same meaning.

    General meaning - there are different ways of saying the same thing, so why not speak with a kinder tongue?
    ~~~~
    ok, so lets move onto the next discussion
    Thanks Maryam. The zarbol masal was particularly interesting!

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by indian_blues View Post
    IMO

    Is the question for the one's who already have a partner?
    Sure.


    I think male are more adventurous, explorative than females.
    Really, what makes you think that?

    And, even if males have more of these things, it doesn't mean that they have more of a preference for different partners. Or does it?

    Originally posted by indian_blues
    i think they wish to have it secretly not damaging the relationship with their primary partner, coz as she was the backbone for his family. The illegal relationship must be ending abruptly coz it was just started to satisfy their short term needs.
    I'm with you here. I see this as somewhat of a reality as well, but maybe a problematic reality that could be altered in a more healthy way. My follow up questions for you are this:

    Would it be better if both in the relationship agreed instead of either making it a secret?

    Is it possible and desirable to satisfy your sexual urges before having a serious relationship?

    Originally posted by indian_blues
    First we need to analyze what is the need for one to have multiple partners? which drives them? is't sex? money? or some other factors?
    I agree that the factors are important. Perhaps we could learn the conditions where relationships are the most healthy.

    Leave a comment:


  • indian_blues
    replied
    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    What are your opinions about whether people prefer multiple partners or not. Even if they shouldn't act on their preference, do you think they generally have that preference?
    IMO

    Since Male and Female are two opposite poles it is impossible to generalize their characteristics for both.

    Is the question for the one's who already have a partner?

    First we need to analyze what is the need for one to have multiple partners? which drives them? is't sex? money? or some other factors?

    I think male are more adventurous, explorative than females. I think males do prefer multiple partners becoz of their natural characteristics and i think they wish to have it secretly not damaging the relationship with their primary partner, coz as she was the backbone for his family. The illegal relationship must be ending abruptly coz it was just started to satisfy their short term needs.
    Last edited by indian_blues; 07-17-2007, 06:59 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • abadani69
    replied
    loooool ramin,mikhay begi ke moderatore khoobi naboodam on moghe baba ey val

    anyways,az bahsemoon kharej nashim
    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    Nagoftam serious nabudi, faghat be nazaram nakhodagah moderatore khubi shodi!

    anyway, mohem neestesh...

    Leave a comment:


  • zubin
    replied
    Originally posted by abadani69 View Post
    Manzooret chi e Ramin?in che rabti be moderator boodan dare? I was serious in what i said.
    Nagoftam serious nabudi, faghat be nazaram nakhodagah moderatore khubi shodi!

    anyway, mohem neestesh...

    Leave a comment:


  • abadani69
    replied
    Manzooret chi e Ramin?in che rabti be moderator boodan dare? I was serious in what i said.

    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    abadan az moghei ke moderator neesti kheyli khub moderate meekoni!
    Maryam khanom, I wasn't joking. Maybe you persian don't follow what our profit used to do, but there are many arabs who is following the profit Mohammad's Law. There is no shame to have more than 1 wife. As long as you can support all of them, then you shouldn't have any problem.

    And about beating women if not having a boy, I agree with you, they shouldn't make any diff between their kids, but back then the readon that they wanted boy was because after they die they wanted their sons take over, but right now this has changed.

    Originally posted by maryam_shirazi_9 View Post
    because back in the day, Muhammad brought that law to essentially protect the women, because society was mis-treating women (i.e. people were building a wall around the baby to kill it if a woman gave birth to a baby girl rather than a baby boy, they were beating women etc)

    Muhammad brought that law because having more than 1 wife enabled the man to protect women.

    but times have changed since way back then - those things no longer happen, so that law is obsolete for the 21st century. Society now accepts men and women equally now

    i know your original post was said in a jokey way

    Leave a comment:

Working...