‘Live India’ channel banned for a month
‘Live India’, the channel which has been in the dock for airing a fake sting operation, has been banned for a month from Thursday.
The ban has been imposed by Information and Broadcasting Ministry by invoking the Cable Television Networks Regulation Act, 1995.
The decision comes about a week after the channel managers responded on September 14 to the Ministry’s show-cause notice asking why its permission to broadcast should not be suspended/revoked. The matter was referred to an Inter-Ministerial Committee (IMC).
The Ministry said the sting operation was “defamatory, deliberate, false and contained suggestive innuendos and half-truths; incited violence and contained content against maintenance of law and order.” Further, according to the statement, the sting operation “criticised, maligned and slandered an individual in person and it denigrated children.”
The IMC was also of the view that it was irresponsible of the channel to have aired the fake sting operation “without exercise of due diligence in preliminary verification of the facts of the case.”
In the order, the Ministry refers to the channel as ‘Janmat’ as its decision to rechristen itself as ‘Live India’ does not have ministerial sanction as yet. Apparently, it had only applied for a name change.
Even before it became clear that the sting operation showing a government school teacher of the capital forcing a student into prostitution had been orchestrated, the Ministry had advised ‘Live India’ to remove its new logo from the channel. That advisory was ignored by the channel and on September 13 it was directed to remove the logo. Again, the channel refused to comply with it.
The controversial telecast had led to rioting near the school and the dismissal of the teacher Uma Khurana. She was arrested and then granted bail.
An Indian television news channel has been taken off air for a month after broadcasting a false "sting" which led to riots and a woman being jailed.
India's Broadcasting Ministry said the report on Live India had been "defamatory, deliberate and false".
Delhi teacher Uma Khurana was accused of forcing students into prostitution. Police later said the report was faked.
Live India is the first news channel to be banned in India. The station says it was misled by its reporter.
The case follows a number of other so-called stings in which people allege they have been framed and has led to renewed calls for India's media to be regulated.
Experts blame a highly competitive media environment where 24-hour news channels are fighting for revenue and viewers' attention.
'Slandered'
The Information and Broadcasting Ministry said on Thursday that Live India, also known as Janmat, had breached the Cable Networks Regulation Act, 1995, by broadcasting "an admittedly doctored sting operation" on Ms Khurana.
The channel has been taken off air until 20 October.
"The telecast of said sting operation was defamatory, deliberate, false and contained suggestive innuendos and half-truths; incited violence and contained content against maintenance of law and order," a statement from the ministry said.
"It criticised, maligned and slandered an individual in person and it denigrated children and was irresponsibly aired by the channel without exercise of due diligence in preliminary verification of the facts of the case.
"Therefore, the central government thought it necessary to prohibit transmission or re-transmission of the said channel throughout the country."
Ms Khurana was ordered to be reinstated in her job by the Delhi high court earlier this month.
There were riots in the city and a mob attacked the school at which Ms Khurana worked, dragged her out and assaulted her after the secretly-filmed tape was broadcast on 30 August. She spent 10 days in prison.
A police investigation later revealed the sting had been faked and the teacher falsely accused.
The undercover journalist, Prakash Singh, who made the report has been arrested.
The ban has been imposed by Information and Broadcasting Ministry by invoking the Cable Television Networks Regulation Act, 1995.
The decision comes about a week after the channel managers responded on September 14 to the Ministry’s show-cause notice asking why its permission to broadcast should not be suspended/revoked. The matter was referred to an Inter-Ministerial Committee (IMC).
The Ministry said the sting operation was “defamatory, deliberate, false and contained suggestive innuendos and half-truths; incited violence and contained content against maintenance of law and order.” Further, according to the statement, the sting operation “criticised, maligned and slandered an individual in person and it denigrated children.”
The IMC was also of the view that it was irresponsible of the channel to have aired the fake sting operation “without exercise of due diligence in preliminary verification of the facts of the case.”
In the order, the Ministry refers to the channel as ‘Janmat’ as its decision to rechristen itself as ‘Live India’ does not have ministerial sanction as yet. Apparently, it had only applied for a name change.
Even before it became clear that the sting operation showing a government school teacher of the capital forcing a student into prostitution had been orchestrated, the Ministry had advised ‘Live India’ to remove its new logo from the channel. That advisory was ignored by the channel and on September 13 it was directed to remove the logo. Again, the channel refused to comply with it.
The controversial telecast had led to rioting near the school and the dismissal of the teacher Uma Khurana. She was arrested and then granted bail.
An Indian television news channel has been taken off air for a month after broadcasting a false "sting" which led to riots and a woman being jailed.
India's Broadcasting Ministry said the report on Live India had been "defamatory, deliberate and false".
Delhi teacher Uma Khurana was accused of forcing students into prostitution. Police later said the report was faked.
Live India is the first news channel to be banned in India. The station says it was misled by its reporter.
The case follows a number of other so-called stings in which people allege they have been framed and has led to renewed calls for India's media to be regulated.
Experts blame a highly competitive media environment where 24-hour news channels are fighting for revenue and viewers' attention.
'Slandered'
The Information and Broadcasting Ministry said on Thursday that Live India, also known as Janmat, had breached the Cable Networks Regulation Act, 1995, by broadcasting "an admittedly doctored sting operation" on Ms Khurana.
The channel has been taken off air until 20 October.
"The telecast of said sting operation was defamatory, deliberate, false and contained suggestive innuendos and half-truths; incited violence and contained content against maintenance of law and order," a statement from the ministry said.
"It criticised, maligned and slandered an individual in person and it denigrated children and was irresponsibly aired by the channel without exercise of due diligence in preliminary verification of the facts of the case.
"Therefore, the central government thought it necessary to prohibit transmission or re-transmission of the said channel throughout the country."
Ms Khurana was ordered to be reinstated in her job by the Delhi high court earlier this month.
There were riots in the city and a mob attacked the school at which Ms Khurana worked, dragged her out and assaulted her after the secretly-filmed tape was broadcast on 30 August. She spent 10 days in prison.
A police investigation later revealed the sting had been faked and the teacher falsely accused.
The undercover journalist, Prakash Singh, who made the report has been arrested.
Comment