Next Stop Iran?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • IQ
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2005
    • 5035

    #1

    Next Stop Iran?

    Why George Bush should resist a Wagnerian exit from the White House
    “WE ARE not planning for a war with Iran.” So said Robert Gates, America's new defence secretary, on February 2nd. You cannot be much clearer than that. With a weak and isolated president, and an army bogged down in the misery of Iraq, the American Congress and people are hardly in fighting mood. Nonetheless, and despite Mr Gates's calming words, Iran and America are heading for a collision. Although the risk is hard to quantify, there exists a real possibility that George Bush will order a military strike on Iran some time before he leaves the White House two years from now.
    America and Iran have been at loggerheads ever since Ayatollah Khomeini's revolution of 1979. But four things are making this old antagonism newly dangerous. One is Iran's apparent determination to build nuclear weapons, and a fear that it is nearing the point where its nuclear programme will be impossible to stop (see article). The second is the advent of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, a populist president who denies the Holocaust and calls openly for Israel's destruction: his apocalyptic speeches have convinced many people in Israel and America that the world is facing a new Hitler with genocidal intent. The third is a recent tendency inside the Bush administration to blame Iran for many of America's troubles not just in Iraq but throughout the Middle East.
    [/SIZE]


    Any one of these would be destabilising enough on its own. Added together, they make the possibility of miscalculation and a slide into war a great deal more likely. That is all the more so when they are combined with a fourth new source of friction between America and Iran. This is the predicament of Mr Bush. A president who is now detached from electoral considerations knows that his place in history is going to be defined by the tests he himself chose to put at the centre of his foreign policy: bringing democracy to the Middle East and preventing rogue regimes from acquiring weapons of mass destruction. Given his excessive willingness to blame Iran for blocking America's noble aims in the Middle East, he may come to see a pre-emptive strike on its nuclear programme as a fitting way to redeem his presidency. That would be a mistake.
    Never attack a revolution

    This newspaper supported America's invasion of Iraq. We believed, erroneously, that Saddam Hussein was working to acquire nuclear weapons. And we judged that the world should not allow a mass-murderer to gather such lethal power in his hands. In the case of Iran, the balance of risks points, though only just, in the other direction.
    Even if it became clear that Iran was on the threshold of acquiring an atomic bomb, an American strike on its nuclear facilities would be a reckless gamble. Without America invading and occupying Iran—unthinkable after Iraq—such a strike would at best delay rather than end Iran's nuclear ambitions. It might very well rally support behind a regime that is at present not conspicuously popular at home, emboldening it to retaliate inside Iraq, against Israel and perhaps against the United States itself. Besides, it is far from clear exactly how dangerous a nuclear-armed Iran would be. Unlike Iraq under Saddam, Iran has a complex power structure with elements of pluralism and many checks and balances. For all its proclaimed religiosity, it has behaved since the revolution like a rational actor. To be sure, some of its regional aims are mischievous, and in pursuing them it has adopted foul means, including terrorism. But the ayatollahs have so far been shrewd calculators of consequences. There are already small signs of a backlash against the attention-seeking Mr Ahmadinejad. Like the Soviet Union, a nuclear Iran could probably be deterred.
    But don't think Iran isn't dangerous

    All of this suggests that in present circumstances it would be wrong for America to launch a military strike against Iran. But it would be the height of self-deception for anyone to jump to the conclusion that a nuclear-armed Iran would not be dangerous at all. It would be very dangerous indeed.
    For a start, there is a danger that Iran's nuclear efforts will provoke a pre-emptive strike by Israel, which is already a nuclear power, albeit an undeclared one. For Israelis, whose country Mr Ahmadinejad says he wants to wipe off the map, it is not all that reassuring to hear that Iran can “probably” be deterred. Even if Israel were to decide against such a strike, Iran's going nuclear could destroy what is left of the international non-proliferation regime. It has proved hard enough for Arab states such as Egypt and Saudi Arabia to live with Israel's undeclared bomb; if their Iranian rival got one too, the race to copy might soon be on. On top of this is the danger that a nuclear Iran would feel safe to ramp up attempts to spread its revolution violently beyond its own borders.
    Every effort should be made to stop an Iranian bomb. But there is a better way than an armed strike. In 2002 Mr Bush consigned Iran along with Iraq and North Korea to an “axis of evil”. Since 2004, for lack of good alternatives, he has been helping the efforts of Britain, France and Germany to talk rather than bludgeon Iran into nuclear compliance. Iran claims that its nuclear programme is for civil purposes only. Last year, the Europeans called its bluff by offering trade, civil-nuclear assistance and a promise of talks with America if it stopped enriching the uranium that could produce the fuel for a bomb. When Iran refused, diplomacy led in December to the imposition of economic sanctions by the Security Council.
    This is a promising approach. The diplomacy at the United Nations proceeds at a glacial pace. But Iran is thought to be several years from a bomb. And meanwhile the Americans, Europeans, Russians and Chinese have at last all lined up on the same side of the argument. What is required now is a further tightening of the economic squeeze coupled with some sort of an incentive—most usefully an unambiguous promise from Mr Bush that if Iran returns to compliance with the nuclear rules it will face no attempt by America to overthrow the regime. Even then, America and Iran may be fated to lock horns in the Middle East. But the region, and the world, will be a good deal safer without the shadow of an Iranian bomb.
    13
    Yes
    61.54%
    8
    No
    38.46%
    5
    Last edited by IQ; 02-09-2007, 06:59 PM.
  • mike435
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2006
    • 2104

    #2
    you beat me to it
    love the economist


    G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


    Comment

    • IQ
      Senior Member
      • Feb 2005
      • 5035

      #3
      I read Economist all the time. I actually read it so I can be ready for the MCAT.

      Comment

      • donsaeid
        Senior Member
        • Nov 2005
        • 28300

        #4
        let them come and we give them same kind of threatment 100 times better! or worse!
        نه غزه نه لبنان جانم فدای ایران


        «در زندگی زخم*هايی هست که مثل خوره روح را آهسته در انزوا می*خورد و می*تراشد.»
        صادق هدايت؛ بوف کور

        Comment

        • IQ
          Senior Member
          • Feb 2005
          • 5035

          #5
          I said in 2003 Iran's regime will change in end of 2006 and everybody disagreed and said it will never change. But now 2 months later you are seeing what is going on. There should be important news about Iran within the next 2-3 weeks. WATCH the news, you'll hear about it.

          Comment

          • zubin
            Member
            • Aug 2006
            • 1567

            #6
            what does regime change even mean? lol...
            Take him and cut him out in little stars,
            and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
            that all the world will be in love with night,
            and pay no worship to the garish sun

            - Shakespeare

            "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

            Comment

            • donsaeid
              Senior Member
              • Nov 2005
              • 28300

              #7
              who is going to take over? that stupid guy who comments everything? that guy who always dreams of being like its father? or someone from that organization which made every member divorce?
              نه غزه نه لبنان جانم فدای ایران


              «در زندگی زخم*هايی هست که مثل خوره روح را آهسته در انزوا می*خورد و می*تراشد.»
              صادق هدايت؛ بوف کور

              Comment

              • IQ
                Senior Member
                • Feb 2005
                • 5035

                #8
                That's a good Question. My answer would be THE PEOPLE.

                Comment

                • donsaeid
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2005
                  • 28300

                  #9
                  Tonight is Last night of deadline for Iran to accept UNSC resolution!
                  نه غزه نه لبنان جانم فدای ایران


                  «در زندگی زخم*هايی هست که مثل خوره روح را آهسته در انزوا می*خورد و می*تراشد.»
                  صادق هدايت؛ بوف کور

                  Comment

                  • donsaeid
                    Senior Member
                    • Nov 2005
                    • 28300

                    #10
                    UNITED NATIONS, Feb 20 (KUNA) -- The Security Council is in a "waiting mood" for a report by Mohamed ElBaradei, head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), which is scheduled to be released later this week on whether Iran complied with UN demands to halt its uranium enrichment activities.

                    The council imposed limited sanctions on Iran last December 23rd for ignoring previous demand to halt enrichment activities and gave the Agency 60 days to report back on the issue. To add further sanctions or suspend the existing ones depend on whether the IAEA reports that Teheran is or is not abiding by the resolution.

                    Although the report is expected to say that Iran has not halted its enrichment activities, as stressed by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad earlier today, council members have not scheduled any meeting yet and are reluctant to say what they have planned for the way ahead.

                    "Not before the report is out," US deputy envoy Alejandro Wolff told reporters on Tuesday.

                    Asked whether the council will impose further sanctions, Wolff said "we'll wait and see the degree to which the resolution has been violated and there will be an appropriate response from the council." While press reports said the report will be out on Wednesday, the UN, however, has announced that the council is "scheduled to hold an open debate on Friday on non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, on the same day that the IAEA is due to turn in a report on Iran." Asked when the report is due, Wolff said "the deadline for the report was to be submitted to the council by February 23rd. So we expect it in the next days." Russian deputy envoy Konstantin Dolgov, however, told reporters that the 60-day period ends tomorrow and that the report "should be out tomorrow" Wednesday, describing it as a "very serious document." He said discussions among the council's five permanent members - US, UK, France, Russia and China - plus Germany are going on, but they are not going on in New York. "New York is not engaged at this point," he said.

                    He added "I understand all discussions are aimed at the diplomatic solution. But resolutions have to be implemented. We'll see what the report will say." Asked whether "diplomatic solution" means Russia is against imposing further sanctions on Iran, Dolgov said "We're not speaking about sanctions right now. We're waiting for the report and we will see how to advance from that point. But obviously, we always said that the only solution can be through negotiations and through engagement. So we will see how it goes." He said it would be "logical" that once the report is out, the P5 plus Germany will get together in the capitals before the whole council deliberates on it.

                    "I don't exclude a six-party meeting in the capitals before," he said, adding "the report has to be studied. It is not that we get the report tomorrow and by the end of tomorrow we will be ready with some course of action." The report will be issued simultaneously in Vienna and New York, UN officials said, adding that the council will take up the issue in early March. Diplomats predicted that Elbaradei will discuss the content of his report with Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon when they meet in Vienna later this week.

                    Ban will also be in Berlin on Wednesday to attend the high-level meeting of the Quartet - UN, US, EU and Russia - on the Middle East.

                    The participants, diplomats also predicted, will discuss the Iranian issue on the margins of the Middle East meeting.
                    نه غزه نه لبنان جانم فدای ایران


                    «در زندگی زخم*هايی هست که مثل خوره روح را آهسته در انزوا می*خورد و می*تراشد.»
                    صادق هدايت؛ بوف کور

                    Comment

                    Working...