Nuclear Crisis

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rasputin
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2005
    • 63906

    #391
    Solana: Iran dialogue can't last forever

    European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana said Wednesday Iran must decide whether it wants to continue nuclear talks.

    "Today, Iran has made no commitment to suspend," Solana told the European Parliament. "This dialogue I am maintaining cannot last forever and it is up to Iranians now to decide whether its time has come to end."

    He said that if that was the case, he suggested that the standoff over Iran's nuclear program be moved to the United Nations Security Council.

    Meanwhile, Vice Premier Shimon Peres, speaking at a press conference in Berlin, said that the international community must adopt an aggressive stance against Iran.

    According to Peres, Iran's strength stemmed from the international community's weakness in responding to it.

    The vice premier said that it was a mistake for Western countries to keep talking with Iran after Teheran failed to meet a deadline to agree to stop enriching uranium.

    "Iran seeks a nuclear bomb, although it already has a human bomb in the image of Ahmadinejad," said Peres.

    Iran let an August 31 deadline pass, failing to agree to an offer of economic incentives in return for dropping its uranium enrichment program.

    Solana has continued to talk with chief Iranian negotiator Ali Larijani.

    Asked what he expected from the talks, Peres said, "If you don't want to govern the world by guns, then you have to govern the world by wills - which means if you say something you must respect it."

    "The fact is, that the United Nations, all countries, gave a date to the Iranians to answer," he said. "The Iranians didn't respect it and the negotiations are still continuing. And I think this is a devaluation of the wills, which is in my judgment mistaken. Don't say it's OK ... you must stick to what you have said."

    "The United States went with Europe for the diplomatic and economic option and they try to build a coalition," Peres said. "Well, a coalition must produce an agreement, otherwise it cannot hold. An agreement must have a time and a date, it cannot be weak, it must be a choice."

    US officials have said they are willing to give Solana up to several more weeks to see if he can reach a deal with Larijani before pressing for sanctions in the UN Security Council.

    iran

    Comment

    • Rasputin
      Senior Member
      • Jan 2005
      • 63906

      #392
      Iran to open nuclear sites to tourists

      Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has ordered authorities to open the doors of Iran's nuclear facilities to foreign tourists in order to prove that the country's disputed nuclear program has been peaceful, state-run television reported on Wednesday.

      "After an order by the president... foreign tourists can visit Iran's nuclear facilities," the head of Iran's tourism division, Esfandiar Rahim Mashai, was quoted as saying.

      Mashai said Ahmadinejad issued the order to show that Iran's nuclear program has been peaceful, and that it aims to generate fuel, not weapons.
      "We are reviewing the related instructions in this regard," he reportedly said.

      The report did not clarify the definition of a foreign tourist. The announcement came a day after Iran's parliament voted to debate a bill that would require the government to fingerprint all US citizens visiting Iran.

      The draft law would require all American citizens to be fingerprinted when they enter Iran. The measure was in retaliation for the fingerprinting of Iranian travelers visiting the United States, a procedure implemented in 2002 for Iranians and citizens of several other countries.

      iran

      Comment

      • Rasputin
        Senior Member
        • Jan 2005
        • 63906

        #393
        سخنگوی وزارت امور خارجه ايران اعلام کرد: تعليق از نظر ما کاملا رد شده است و به هيج وجه قابل پذيرش نيست.
        به گزارش خبرنگار سياسی مهر، سيد محمد علی حسيني، سخنگوی جديد وزارت امور خارجه، در نخستين نشست خبری خود با خبرنگاران افزود: آنچه رسانه ها از آن تحت عنوان تعليق چند روزه يا يک روزه ياد می کنند به هيچ عنوان در سياست جمهوری اسلامی ايران جايی ندارد.

        وی تاکيد کرد: ايران بر حقوق خود طبق ان پی تی پا فشاری می کند و هيچ پيش شرطی را برای مذاکره نمی پذيرد.

        iran

        Comment

        • Rasputin
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2005
          • 63906

          #394
          Iran rejects six nations' demands

          Iran has refused to suspend its uranium enrichment programme after six key countries agreed to discuss possible sanctions against Tehran.
          A spokesman for Iran's foreign ministry said suspension was "unacceptable" and the threat of sanctions "inefficient".

          The five permanent UN Security Council members and Germany held talks in the UK on Friday to discuss Iran's repeated refusal to halt nuclear activities.

          Despite fears it is developing nuclear arms, Iran says its aims are peaceful.

          "The suspension is completely unacceptable and we have rejected it," foreign ministry spokesman Mohammad Ali Hosseini told reporters.

          "The threat of sanctions is an inefficient means to achieve a solution," he said.

          Russia and China favour diplomacy, not sanctions. A UN debate on punitive action could start as early as next week.

          'Time limited'

          Speaking after discussions in London, UK Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett said the six powers would "consult on measures under article 41 of Chapter 7 of the UN Charter".


          Iran's nuclear programme is popular with many in the country

          Article 41 authorises the Security Council to apply non-military means, such as economic or diplomatic sanctions, "to give effect to its decisions".

          EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana said earlier that "the door to negotiations is and will be always open", despite saying earlier this week that little progress had been made in his "endless hours" of talks with Tehran.

          He said the issue could only be solved through negotiations, although talks could not go on forever.

          The six nations - the UK, Russia, China, France, the US and Germany - had offered Iran a package of incentives in return for the suspension of its uranium enrichment programme.

          Iran missed a 31 August UN Security Council deadline to stop work, after which the US agreed to allow Mr Solana to continue talks with Tehran.

          But BBC diplomatic correspondent James Robbins says the major powers now seem to accept that Iran is not prepared to meet their demand for a halt.

          'Extreme measures'

          There are sharp differences between the six countries attending the meeting on what kind of sanctions to possibly impose on Iran.


          Tehran says it will not give up its nuclear programme
          The US and the UK favour immediate punitive sanctions, but in order to win over Russia and China, they are believed to be considering a series of low-level sanctions as a first step.

          These would be what British officials describe as incremental, proportional and reversible.

          They could include travel restrictions on Iranian officials and embargoes on missile and nuclear technology that could have dual civilian-military use.

          But China and Russia have both said diplomacy is still the best way to achieve a solution.

          On Thursday, Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov described sanctions as "extreme measures".

          He said he would like to "see what extra possibilities exist to pursue multiparty diplomatic efforts".

          Russia has built a nuclear power station in Iran and China relies on oil imports from the country.

          iran

          Comment

          • Rasputin
            Senior Member
            • Jan 2005
            • 63906

            #395
            كره آزمايش اتمی كرد، اما بوش ايران و سوريه را تهديد كرد!
            آزمايش اتمی كره شمالی
            مشوق حمله ايران شد؟




            آزمايش اتمی كره شمالی كه گفته می شود قدرت آن كمی بيش از قدرت انفجار اتمی هيروشيما، در پايان جنگ دوم جهانی بود، بهانه ای تحريك آميز برای موضع گيری تند تر امريكا عليه ايران شد. بوش در بخشی از پيام كوتاهی كه چند ساعت پس از آزمايش از طريق راديو داد، مدعی شد:

            «كره شمالی گسترش*دهنده شماره يك فن آوری موشكی در جهان است. اين كشور به ايران و سوريه نيز اين فناوری را صادر مي*كند. انتقال تسليحات هسته*ای يا مواد آن به كشورها و گروههای ديگر توسط كره شمالی خطری بزرگ برای آمريكا شناخته مي*شود و پيونگ يانگ كاملا مسئوليت عواقب آن را بايد قبول كند. من به متحدين در منطقه شامل كره جنوبی و ژاپن مجددا تاكيد مي*كنم كه واشنگتن آماده اجرای تعهدات امنيتی و بازدارنده بصورت تمام و كمال است.»

            دراين پيام بيش از آنكه كره شمالی مخاطب باشد، ايران و سوريه كه تاكنون بحثی در باره اتمی بودن آن مطرح نبود مخاطب اند! بوش در پيام خود، درعين حال كه روی قاطعيت امريكا برای تعهدات امنيتی و بازدارنده تاكيد كرد، روی ادامه ديپلماسی با كره نيز تاكيد كرد، درحاليكه چنين تاكيدی روی جمله تهديد آميزی كه در ارتباط با ايران و سوريه بكار برد وجود نداشت. متن پيام، كوتاهی و سمت گيری آن، آشكار ساخت كه كاخ سفيد آزمايش اتمی كره شمالی را درخدمت اهداف خود برای حمله به ايران می خواهد به كار بگيرد و چنين تبليغ كند كه حمله پيشگيرانه به ايران، از شكل گيری يك كره شمالی در خاورميانه جلوگيری می كند و ضمنا تاخير در اين اقدام، به همان نتايجی می انجامد كه دركره شمالی انجاميد!

            بايد ديد، درجمهوری اسلامی آزمايش اتمی كره شمالی مشوقی برای طرفداران توليد سلاح اتمی درايران می شود و يا شده و يا ارزيابی بالا بعنوان هشداری جدی مورد نظر قرار گرفته است.



            iran

            Comment

            • Rasputin
              Senior Member
              • Jan 2005
              • 63906

              #396
              نطنز
              مشهور ترين شهر ايران








              هفته نامه اشپيگل تاريخ 8 اكتبر (شماره 41) با انتشار يك عكس هوائی از تاسيسات اتمی نطنز، درگزارش مشروحی پيرامون فعاليت های اتمی ايران نوشت: مناقشه اتمی ايران وارد مرحله ديگری شده است و پرونده آن به شواری امنيت واگذار می شود. ايران تا پايان تابستان مهلت بازگشت به پشت ميز مذاكره را داشت و حال فقط محاصره اقتصادی می تواند ايران را زير فشار بگذارد. اين هفته نامه از قول وزير امور خارجه آلمان نوشت:
              «ما می خواهيم با هم پيمان های خود در باره طرح اين قطعنامه در شورای امنيت گفتگو كنيم.»
              اين درحالی است كه لاوروف وزير امور خارجه روسيه می گويد: ما بايد تمام توان خود را برای كشاندن ايران به پشت ميز مذاكره به كار ببريم.



              iran

              Comment

              • Rasputin
                Senior Member
                • Jan 2005
                • 63906

                #397
                Iran says 'hostile' to nuclear weapons after NKorea test

                TEHRAN (AFP)Iran said it was "hostile" towards the development of nuclear weapons, a day after North Korea claimed an atomic weapons test, but said the big powers have to start disarmament.

                "The Islamic Republic is hostile to the production and utilisation of nuclear weapons and to destruction," said government spokesman Gholam Hossein Elham.

                "The best solution to combat nuclear weapons is for the big powers to start by destroying them themselves," he was quoted as saying by the official IRNA news agency.

                He pledged Tehran's help if the world's nuclear powers were serious in achieving this goal.

                The five UN Security Council permanent members, Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States, plus Germany, are expected to begin discussing this week a resolution imposing sanctions on Tehran if it does not halt its own nuclear program.

                Tehran insists its nuclear program is solely for peaceful energy needs, vehemently rejecting allegations that it is seeking nuclear weapons.

                Following North Korea's announcement Monday of its weapons test, Iran said it wants a world "free of nuclear weapons".

                "Iran's position is clear and Iran on principle believes in a world free of nuclear weapons," foreign ministry spokesman Mohammad Ali Hosseini was quoted as saying by a state television anchor.

                iran

                Comment

                • Rasputin
                  Senior Member
                  • Jan 2005
                  • 63906

                  #398
                  Iran: Nuke disarmament must begin with Israel

                  Iranian government spokesperson Gholam-Hossein Elham tells press conference ‘dismantling of nuclear arms in Middle East must begin with Zionist entity’; adds: Ban to use weapons of mass destruction should be imposed globally

                  Iranian government spokesperson Gholam-Hossein Elham told a press conference Tuesday that “the dismantling of nuclear arms in the Middle East must begin with the Zionist entity.”

                  The spokesperson added that Iran was ‘ideologically opposed’ to the use of nuclear arms.

                  However, North Korea’s nuclear test has prompted Iran to call on the International Atomic Energy Agency to brace itself for the possibility that all countries would seek nuclear energy for “peaceful purposes.”



                  Elham said the ban to use weapons of mass destruction should be imposed globally.



                  “A just balance would remove these (nuclear) threats, and the conquering regime from Jerusalem should be the first in the region to disarm,” he said.



                  Turning his attention to the North Korean nuclear test, the spokesperson said, “Iran is opposed to any use of weapons of mass destruction, particularly nuclear weapons. He added that Muslim and other countries would support the superpowers should they decide to disarm.




                  “No one will benefit from the use of nuclear weapons,” he said.




                  'US should stop its double-standard policy'

                  Asked whether the North Korean test would be advantageous to Iran Elham said, “The root of the issue lies in the behavior and mindset of the leaders in the United States and the rest of the superpowers. Unfortunately, they are those who control the Security Council; they possess the arsenals and are taking advantage of the Council to promote their own objectives.”



                  Alaeddin Boroujerdi, chairman of the Majlis (Iranian parliament) National Security and Foreign Policy Commission, told the Iranian News Agency Monday that “the only solution which can put an end to nuclear tests is collective determination of the global community to eradicate proliferation of nuclear weapons.”
                  “The US should stop its double-standard policy in the world; it is the only country that has resorted to the use of nuclear bombs to massacre innocent civilians and is continuing its current policy in contradiction of Article Six of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT),” he said.




                  Boroujerdi added: “If countries like Pakistan, India, North Korea and the Zionist regime kept up their nuclear tests, it is because of their non-compliance with international rules and regulations along with their non-membership of NPT.”



                  “The West should encourage and cooperate with countries, like the Islamic Republic of Iran, which abide by NPT protocol and conduct their activities under the supervision of IAEA in line with international rules and regulations,” he said.

                  iran

                  Comment

                  • Rasputin
                    Senior Member
                    • Jan 2005
                    • 63906

                    #399
                    Khamenei defends nuclear 'right'

                    Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the Supreme Leader of Iran, says the country will continue developing nuclear technology.
                    "Our policy is clear, progress with clear logic and insisting on the nation's right without any retreat," state television quoted him as saying.

                    His comments come as the United Nations discusses its response to North Korea's claimed nuclear test on Monday.

                    Iran has always maintained the technology is for peaceful purposes and not for atomic weapons.

                    Last week, at talks in London, the six major powers trying to persuade Iran to curtail its nuclear research agreed to consult on the possibility of imposing sanctions.

                    The Ayatollah's comments are his first public remarks since the meeting.

                    'Full confidence'

                    He was also quoted as saying that while Iran had previously suspended its enrichment program, it would not do so again.

                    "Now with steady heart and full confidence we press ahead and nobody can give a good reason that the nuclear path is wrong for the country," he said.

                    Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was also quoted by state television, saying the country would continue to negotiate and cooperate in the nuclear energy field.


                    Iran says their nuclear intentions are peaceful

                    "Iran's proposal is an appropriate framework for cooperation in the nuclear issue and the Iranian nation will continue the path of dignity with perseverance and prudence without any fear."

                    Tehran had rejected a 31 August deadline set by the UN Security Council that it suspend enrichment or face possible sanctions.

                    At the London talks last week, the US and the UK favoured immediate punitive sanctions, but China and Russia both said diplomacy was still the best way to achieve a solution.

                    iran

                    Comment

                    • Rasputin
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2005
                      • 63906

                      #400
                      Iran has called the west's bluff on the nuclear standoff

                      The US cannot risk imposing stricter sanctions or military action. Fairness is now the only option


                      As the Iranian and American presidents offer their rival versions of international reality at the United Nations this week, it is worth recalling that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is not the first Iranian leader to travel to New York to proclaim his country's right to make its own decisions about energy resources, to denounce imperialism, and to condemn a world order weighted in favour of a handful of powerful nations.
                      In this same month in 1951, Dr Mohammad Mossadeq convinced the UN that British efforts to regain control of the oil industry the Iranian government had just nationalised did not deserve the world body's support. Mossadeq won over the security council, and he won over the United States, which enjoyed the spectacle of this elderly, eccentric and eloquent man challenging the British empire. American reporters affectionately nicknamed him "Old Mossy".

                      How different is the scene at the UN today, with Bush castigating Iran for political suppression at home, for supporting terrorism abroad, and for pursuing nuclear weapons, while Ahmadinejad portrays the US as the leader of a group of nations which have hijacked international institutions in pursuit of their own narrow interests. Between these two moments on the East River lies a half century in which the US was transformed, in Iranian eyes, from the angel in international affairs that Mossadeq had imagined into the demon scourged by Ayatollah Khomeini and most of his successors.
                      "Old Mossy" hoped America would help Iran become truly independent. Instead, America joined Britain in removing him from power and ensconcing the Shah as an authoritarian ruler. Most Iranians, including opponents of the regime, think the US has never redeemed itself for that act, or for its later meddling in Iranian affairs. American intervention would reach a malign climax, they say, if the US were to attack Iranian nuclear installations. Just as Iranians believe the US has never made up for the wrong it perpetrated in 1953, so Americans believe the Islamic republic demonstrated, by its seizure of American diplomats in 1979, a deeply unreasonable and probably permanent hostility towards America. The two nations, in other words, bulk pathologically large in each other's vision, and that is the ultimate problem which makes an accommodation between them on nuclear matters, let alone a more general rapprochement, so difficult to achieve.

                      The drama which began three years ago when Britain, France and Germany undertook to bring Iran round on the nuclear issue has had its comic dimension, as European wiliness encountered Iranian guile, and was usually outmatched by it. But now comedy threatens to tip over into farce, and tragedy lies in wait. After the passing of many deadlines, the latest at the end of last month, the Iranians are still enriching uranium. They have so far suffered no consequences, and even if a very modest package of sanctions were to survive Russian and Chinese objections at the UN, it would not hurt the Iranians much, if at all.

                      The western bluff has been called. The Europeans have moved from making suspension a condition for talks to contriving formulas to allow talks to begin without it. As long as serious sanctions lay in the far future, the Europeans were ready to act as if they, and even the highly sceptical Russians and Chinese, would be prepared to take strong measures. But as soon as they become a real prospect, the excuses emerge, ranging from the lack of adequate inducements to the absence of conclusive proof of Iran's nuclear intentions and the danger of pushing the Tehran regime into too tight a corner. All have some substance, but nevertheless represent a retreat from previous positions.

                      In the unlikely event that strong sanctions were imposed, Iran would find it relatively easy to survive them, and they would play into the hands of those in the Iranian government, including Ahmadinejad, who may well believe that a good relationship with the west is a contradiction in terms - something that would sully the revolutionary purity of the republic. So there are indeed reasons for caution on sanctions. In any case the real sanction has been the prospect that if negotiations were to end in total failure, they would be followed, no doubt after a period in which economic measures would be shown to be ineffective, by American military action. The bunker-busters would go in and parts of Iran would be dug up and ploughed under by a bombing campaign, aimed both at destroying installations and killing scientists, which would set back Iran's nuclear programme by three or four years.

                      Yet even if the Bush administration was less weakened by Iraq than it is, the chances of it choosing this option are somewhat less than they may have seemed some months ago. There is no readiness in the country to accept another military enterprise, even if it "only" involved air action, and anyone ordering it would suffer grievous political damage. This would come not so much in the campaign itself, but with the inevitable retaliation by Iran in Iraq and elsewhere in the Middle East. The US government would be wide open to the charge of making a bad mess worse, and the charge would be true, something which it may now be beginning to grasp. It will not rule out the counter-proliferation option, and the American military will continue to plan for it on a contingency basis, but the Iranians are probably right to conclude that it is not a very immediate threat.

                      But it is in the nature of the relationship between Iran and the west that as one danger recedes, another advances. If the Iranian regime comes to believe that both the Europeans and the US are paper tigers, it will be both strengthened and emboldened. At home, the consequences may well be to quicken the pace of the regime's encroachments on the freedom and democracy the Iranian system still displays. Abroad, they could give a push to the sort of adventurism which would make war between Iran and the US a stronger possibility. The only answer is a Middle Eastern policy which stresses needs, rights and fairness more than threats and enemies. Easy generalities, but somewhere in that direction lies the solution, if there is one to be found.

                      iran

                      Comment

                      • Rasputin
                        Senior Member
                        • Jan 2005
                        • 63906

                        #401
                        Strain shows on world's antinuke rules

                        WASHINGTON – The world's patchwork of nuclear nonproliferation treaties and agreements hasn't yet been ripped apart - but it's under strain as never before.
                        North Korea's apparent test of a nuclear device this week is but the latest shock to an international regimen that for the most part has been remarkably successful since its construction at the dawn of the atomic age, more than 40 years ago.

                        The challenge now may be to rally the globe's big powers into a more solid League Against the Spread of Nukes. Potential proliferators such as Iran may be likely to forge ahead unless they see that the US, China, and Russia are willing to forgo business deals, or pay more for oil, to help control nuclear weapons.

                        "You want to show the Iranians that we're actually willing to take some risks on our own to act against nuclear weapons," says George Perkovich, a nuclear strategy and nonproliferation expert at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington.

                        The main element of what experts call the world's nonproliferation architecture is the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), which was opened for signatures on July 1, 1968, in New York. It's augmented by more informal agreements, such as the Nuclear Suppliers Group, and various country-to-country pacts and regional nuclear-free zones.

                        Deviations from the pact

                        In general, it has been successful. North Korea is the only country that has acquired nuclear weapons after signing the NPT. (Pyongyang withdrew from the treaty in 2003.) India and Pakistan have developed an atomic arsenal in recent decades, and Israel is thought to have one, but none of them signed the NPT to begin with.

                        The number of nations with declared weapons, officially seven (not including North Korea), is far smaller than US intelligence reports of the 1960s predicted. Most important, no atomic weapon has been detonated in anger since the United States dropped the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs in 1945.

                        Today this nonuse seems natural, considering the terrible nature of the weapons, but it wasn't foreordained. Back in the early 1960s, when ads for bomb shelters were a common sight, many experts thought it was only a matter of time until someone dropped a bomb.

                        Thomas Schelling, a renowned strategic deterrence theorist, considers nuclear nonuse such a remarkable development that he made it the theme of his acceptance address before the Swedish Academy when he won the Nobel Prize in economics in 2005.

                        In the 1960s, "If I had said, 'Oh, come on, nobody is going to use nuclear weapons for the next 40 years,' everybody would have thought I was out of my mind," said Mr. Schelling at a Council on Foreign Relations event earlier this year.

                        But now, the global status quo on nuclear weapons is being shaken as never before by the twin threats of Iran and North Korea.

                        Iran, an NPT signatory, has in essence been caught in the act of violating the pact, via revelations of covert fissile-material programs.

                        "If Iran can look us in the eyes and say, 'We're going ahead,' what does that say for the system?" says Mr. Perkovich of Carnegie.

                        North Korea, meanwhile, has a long history of exporting its weapons systems to unsavory customers with cash. Preventing Pyongyang from proliferating nuclear devices to terrorists may now be one of the biggest security challenges faced by the US and the rest of the developed world.

                        Proposal for a global alliance

                        The US can't win a war on nuclear terrorism alone, notes Graham Allison, director of the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at Harvard's John F. Kennedy School of Government in Cambridge, Mass.

                        He recommends declaration of a GAANT - Global Alliance Against Nuclear Terrorism.

                        "Establishment of a Global Alliance Against Nuclear Terrorism could help us overcome the psychological barriers to sustained, focused action," writes Dr. Allison in the latest issue of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists.

                        Among other things, such an organization could establish a more robust regimen to control trade in nuclear materials and know-how, including some sort of enforcement mechanism, writes Allison.

                        It could also provide a formal infrastructure for such efforts as joint exercises in tracking hypothetical nuclear terrorists.

                        To get the international cooperation needed to stop covert trade in fissile materials, the US might also consider developing something that Robert Gallucci, dean of Georgetown University's Edmund Walsh School of Foreign Service, dubs "expanded deterrence."

                        Fissile material, like a person, has unique identifying characteristics. A US crash program might develop the capability to identify where any fissile material came from.

                        The US could then announce that it would treat a nuclear attack on the US as an attack by both the perpetrator and the country from which the weapon's fissile material was obtained - meaning US weapons might attack both targets in retaliation.

                        "It may be that, by threatening unacceptable consequences, we can deter that which we cannot physically prevent," writes Mr. Gallucci in the Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science.

                        iran

                        Comment

                        • Rasputin
                          Senior Member
                          • Jan 2005
                          • 63906

                          #402
                          The Khomeini letter

                          A written correspondence between the late Ayatollah Khomeini and the then commander of the Iranian Revolutionary Guards (IRGC), Mohsen Rezai, has given some insight into why Iran accepted a ceasefire with Iraq in 1988. The correspondence has caused much debate and speculation inside and outside Iran. Published by the office of former Iranian president Rafsanjani last week, it reveals that Khomeini had been advised by Rezai that the war was not winnable. While Western observers have focused on a single sentence in the letter referring to nuclear weapons, the letter has sparked fierce debate inside Iran for a very different reason.

                          “ No victories are in sight for the next five years,” Rezai’s letter to Khomeini reads. “If we become able to organize 350 infantry brigades, purchase 2,500 tanks, 3,000 cannons, and 300 war planes, and be able to manufacture laser and nuclear weapons which are nowadays among the necessities of modern warfare, then, God willing, we can think of offensive war activities.”

                          Western media attention has focused on the segment insinuating the IRGC commander’s desire to obtain a nuclear weapon. By doing so, Western audiences have missed critical nuances that are emerging from Iran’s internal debate on the nuclear issue.

                          Inside Iran, little attention has been paid to the letter’s reference to nuclear weapons. Some attribute this to Iran’s invisible red lines on discussing topics that could jeopardize Iran’s negotiating position in the current nuclear stand-off. Another and perhaps more probable explanation is that the Iranian public generally understands that the late Ayatollah did not take Rezai’s desire for more advanced weapons seriously. Rezai’s statements seem to be treated as hyperbole by the Ayatollah. “We need to double the military and increase the IRGC seven fold, and even evict the Americans from the Persian Gulf (which we cannot) [in order to defeat the Iraqis]; nonetheless, we have to continue the war,” Rezai wrote. Khomeini’s comments were brief but conclusive. “This is nothing but sloganeering,” he responded.

                          Government-imposed censorship has prevented a public debate on the war to determine why it was permitted to drag on for over eight years. The issue was raised by both reformers and journalists like Akbar Ganji during the tenure of President Khatami, but their efforts to address the issue were blocked. The publication of the letter occurred as the blame game once again was flaring. The purported differences between Mohsen Rezai and Rafsanjani seem to contribute to this altercation.

                          Arch conservatives in Iran have accused Rafsanjani of “illegal disclosure of the country’s secrets,” going as far as accusing him of “treason.” President Ahmadinejad, whose hostility to Rafsanjani is well known, commented on the letter by saying that “some people” were trying to endear themselves to foreigners. This view enjoys support even among reformists, who found the timing of the publication self-serving.

                          Rafsanjani, who Khomeini assigned to command the war towards its end, continues to have access to many of Iran’s state secrets. Publicizing the letter, his critics argue, serves many of the former president’s interests. On the one hand, the letter reveals that Rezai was responsible for putting an end to the war and not Rafsanjani. (Rafsanjani has on many occasions been criticized by Iranian war veterans for having ended the war in Iran’s disfavor.) On the other hand, some argue the letter is a publicity stunt aimed at raising Rafsanjani’s profile in the wake of his likely candidacy to the Assembly of Experts. A highly contested election, the Assembly of Experts is in charge of electing and supervising Iran’s Supreme Leader. The arch conservative Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi, a key supporter of President Ahmadinejad, is rumored to be seeking to take control of this body. As such, the publication of the letter may be part of the ongoing rivalry between the arch-conservatives and the pragmatists around Rafsanjani.

                          Yet a more salient interpretation, suggested by some observers inside Iran, is that Rafsanjani publicized the letter to warn firebrands in the Iranian government not to take the risk for a US-Iran war lightly. The letter shows that the leader of the Iranian revolution succumbed to the realities of war and peace and chose to compromise in order to avert an even greater disaster. As such, the letter sends a clear signal to Ayatollah Khamenei and President Ahmadinejad – who may feel they have invested too much of their prestige in developing nuclear technology – that the war machine can be stopped if Iranian leaders recognize Iran’s limitations and seek a compromise with the West.

                          Abbas Abdi, a leading reformer echoed this view. “If the war against Saddam needed such a large sum of weapons and equipment, just imagine how much logistics, weaponry, and [what size] economy are needed to fight those who defeated Saddam in [less than] a month,” he wrote. (Abdi, Abbas, Chand nokteh hashiei dar bareh nameh emam). Seyyed Mohammad Ali Abtahi, a former adviser to President Khatami and outspoken critic of the policies of President Ahmadinejad, sought to turn attention to the message of the letter rather than its publication. “The courage to accept the reality is no less than the courage of fighting a war,” he wrote of Rafsanjani’s message in publicizing the letter. “Let’s discuss Imam [Khomeini’s] realistic [turn about] rather than why a secret of the state has been revealed.” (Abtahi, Seyyed Mohammad Ali, Dar bareh enteshar nameh emam tavassot Hashemi).

                          At a minimum, the revelation of the correspondence has paved the way for a debate on this most critical issue as it reveals Iran’s diversity of views on the nuclear issue. The publication of the letter by a former president and by Iran’s media is highly significant. It demonstrates that there is a whole segment of Iran’s leadership structure at the highest levels and within the population that may oppose engulfing Iran in a conflict with the US. Absent direct talks between the US and Iran, it will likely remain difficult for the United States to understand these Iranian dynamics and it will delay Washington’s ability to influence Iran’s internal debates.

                          iran

                          Comment

                          • Rasputin
                            Senior Member
                            • Jan 2005
                            • 63906

                            #403
                            Prime minister discusses Iranian, North Korean nuclear threat to Israel with top security officials, says he backs plans to impose sanctions against Iran for rejecting compromise by western nations

                            Prime Minister Ehud Olmert stressed Thursday that the North Korean nuclear test illustrates the need for the international community to deal in an urgent, determined, courageous and united manner with the nuclear issue.

                            Olmert spoke during a meeting with top security officials to discuss the Iranian nuclear threat to Israel.

                            During the meeting, which was held behind closed doors, officials discussed the steps that need to be taken by the international community to prevent the spread of nuclear armament.

                            At the end of the meeting Olmert said the international community is leading the effort to halt Iran's nuclear program and that Israel backs plans to impose sanctions against Iran at the United Nations Security Council.

                            Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, Vice Premier Shimon Peres, Defense Minister Amir Peretz, Deputy Prime Minister Eliyahu Yishai, and Internal Security Minister Avi Dichter attended the meeting.

                            UN sanctions

                            On Tuesday the five permanent members of the UN Security Council agreed to start working on UN sanctions against Iran next week but failed to bridge differences on how harsh the penalties should be, diplomats and officials said.

                            ”All agree for the need for sanctions but there are problems with how harsh they should be,” said one of the diplomats, whose country is accredited to the IAEA.

                            On Wednesday, Iran's hard-line President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said that he would declare a "Day of national celebration" if sanctions were imposed on his country, state television reported.

                            "The day sanctions are imposed on Iran by its enemies, would be a day of national celebration for the Iranian nation," he was quoted as telling supporters in Robat Karim, a town in south of Tehran.

                            He said previous sanctions had not stopped Iran from achieving its goals.

                            "Iran has achieved nuclear technology under sanctions," Ahmadinejad reportedly said.

                            iran

                            Comment

                            • Rasputin
                              Senior Member
                              • Jan 2005
                              • 63906

                              #404
                              نمايندگان وزراى خارجه پنج عضو دائمى شوراى امنيت و آلمان روز گذشته بر سر تحريم دولت ايران به توافق دست نيافتند. ,مك كورمك, سخنگوى وزارت خارجه آمريكا گفت كه طى يك كنفرانس ويديوئى، نمايندگان وزراى خارجه گروه ,پنج به اضافه يك, عليرغم اتفاق نظر در مورد تحريم ايران، موفق نشدند در مورد جزئيات يك قطعنامه به توافق دست يابند. بنا به تائيد سخنگوى وزارت خارجه آمريكا، پيشنهادات ارائه شده در اين كنفرانس به سفراى گروه ,پنج به اضافه يك, ارائه خواهد شد. از سوى ديگر ,نيكلاوس برنز, معاون وزرات خارجه آمريكا گفت از آنجائى كه شوراى امنيت در حال بررسى موضوع آزمايش اتمى كره شمالى است، مشاوره در زمينه مناقشه اتمى با ايران، ممكن است چند روز ديگر به تاخير بيافتد.

                              iran

                              Comment

                              • Rasputin
                                Senior Member
                                • Jan 2005
                                • 63906

                                #405
                                اظهارنظر يکی از نمايندگان حزب محافظه کار در مجلس عوام بريتانيا درباره برنامه اتمی ايران واکنش شديدی در پی داشته و يکی از نمايندگان خواهان اخراج او از حزب محافظه کار شده است.
                                بوريس جانسون، نماينده محافظه کار مجلس عوام بريتانيا طی مقاله ای در روزنامه ديلی تلگراف نوشته که غرب بايد در مناقشه ای که بر سر فعاليت اتمی ايران با اين کشور دارد، اعتراف به "کيش - مات" يعنی شکست کند.

                                او همچنين نوشته که به سياستمداران ايرانی که به گفته وی به دنبال سلاح اتمی هستند حق می دهد و شايد اکنون زمان آن فرارسيده باشد که به ايران اجازه برخورداری از سلاح اتمی داده شود.

                                بوريس جانسون نوشته است: "ايرانيها بالاخره روزی صاحب بمب اتم می شوند و ما هم يقيناً هيچ کاری نمی توانيم بکنيم، همه جاروجنجال و تهديدها هم بی فايده است ... حتی ممکن است کار به جايی برسد که به ايرانيها بمب اتم هم بدهيم، بله، شايد وقت آن رسيده باشد که آمريکاييها اين روند توقف ناپذير را خودشان مهار کنند".

                                وی افزوده است: "به نظر من دستيابی ايران به بمب [اتم] نه تنها اجتناب ناپذير است بلکه مطابق با خواست مردم اين کشور است و اگر نظر من درست باشد، شايد بتوانيم همه چيز را از اول شروع کنيم ... شايد وقت آن رسيده باشد که به اين وضعيت پر از هراس و سوء ظن و وحشت خاتمه دهيم".

                                اين نماينده مجلس بريتانيا پيشنهاد داده است که آمريکاييها حتی به دستيابی ايران به سلاح اتمی کمک هم بکنند اما به اين شرط که رهبران ايران از "رجزخوانی" درباره اسرائيل دست بردارند و بسوی دموکراسی گام بردارند.

                                بوريس جانسون نوشته که اگر آمريکاييها به دستيابی ايران به سلاح اتمی کمک کنند، مردم ايران هم قدر اين کار آمريکاييها را خواهد دانست و احساس خواهند کرد که به جای اينکه چهره ای وحشتناکی از آنان در جهان ترسيم شود، در امور جهانی سهيم شده اند.

                                او نوشته که اگر به جای نماينده مجلس عوام بريتانيا، مثلاً نماينده قم در مجلس ايران می بود، وظيفه ميهنی خود می دانست که کشورش را هر چه سريعتر به بزرگترين، پر زرق و برق ترين، برنده ترين و مخربترين جنگ افزارهايی که در بازار وجود دارد تجهيز کند و از ته دل و بر اساس عقل و خرد بر اين باور می بود که دارا بودن بمب اتم و توان به کارگيری آن تنها راه مطمئن برای حفاظت از کشور و مردم حوزه انتخابيه اش در قم در مقابل حمله احتمالی آمريکا می بود.

                                بوريس جانسون سخنگوی حزب محافظه کار در مورد مسائل آموزش عالی است و از نمايندگان برجسته اين حزب به شمار می رود.

                                به دنبال انتشار مقاله آقای جانسون در روزنامه ديلی تلگراف، اندرو مک کينلی، عضو کميسيون امورخارجی مجلس عوام بريتانيا از حزب کارگر، نظر او را در مورد مسئله اتمی ايران "فوق العاده خطرناک و غيرمسئولانه" خوانده و از دبيرکل حزب محافظه کار خواسته که او را از حزب اخراج کند.

                                بوريس جانسون در حالی به سياستمداران ايرانی حق داده به دنبال سلاح اتمی باشند که سياستمداران ايرانی در ديدگاههای رسمی خود برنامه هسته ای کشورشان را کاملاً در راستای مقاصد صلحجويانه می دانند و با دستيابی به سلاح اتمی مخالفت می ورزند.

                                اين در حالی است که دولت بريتانيا از برنامه اتمی ايران ابراز نگرانی می کند و خواهان محدود شدن فعاليت اتمی ايران، بخصوص در زمينه غنی سازی اورانيوم است.


                                iran

                                Comment

                                Working...