exactly. and this proves its a race, cultural and socio-economic issue (hegemony). the only motivation for so-called "macho" guys to blame the victim is some subjective arrogance and superiority.
"Iranian-American Student Abused
Collapse
X
-
Take him and cut him out in little stars,
and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
that all the world will be in love with night,
and pay no worship to the garish sun
- Shakespeare
"In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill
-
man i so i wish i was their to make a seen like mostafa
that dud is gonne milke what happend to him like their is no tomarrow
all the while the ****ing ediot of a cop still works their
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
first off, he didnt make a scene. I would like to have seen what YOU would have done if you were in his position. second, if the cop is still at work, lets see how mostafa can milk this. obviously the cop is not scared if he is still working. what happened was wrong, hamin!
Comment
-
what happend was wrong no doutOriginally posted by golgol85 View Postfirst off, he didnt make a scene. I would like to have seen what YOU would have done if you were in his position. second, if the cop is still at work, lets see how mostafa can milk this. obviously the cop is not scared if he is still working. what happened was wrong, hamin!
but he was asked to leav and he wanted to be a tuff guy
than copes came and used excesesive force
i dono how i would react how do you expect me to react when 5000 volts are running throgh my body i probably would disobay even more because that would be my only tool of fighting back
when i say milk i mean sue infact he is partying right now that the police is working whatch how much his going to sue for
or not sue make somthing out of it
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
"you dont get the full picture"Originally posted by IQ View Post
"snipit of a video" 7 minutes is not enogh !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
what is full picture, your biased opinion, a writen police report
a photograph
lol
lol
lol
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
even if he was being a tough guy, adam ke nakoshte bood ke injoori bahash kardan. Why do we have cops? to protect us, not to harm us, especially when we arent doing anything wrong. I am glad I wasnt there, I dont know what i would have done, but I wouldnt have been able to stand there and watch, this i promise you.Originally posted by mike435 View Postwhat happend was wrong no dout
but he was asked to leav and he wanted to be a tuff guy
than copes came and used excesesive force
i dono how i would react how do you expect me to react when 5000 volts are running throgh my body i probably would disobay even more because that would be my only tool of fighting back
when i say milk i mean sue infact he is partying right now that the police is working whatch how much his going to sue for
or not sue make somthing out of it
I dont know you well enough to expect anything form you, but I did know you I would expect you to have enough guts to stand up for yourself, thats all i expect of anyone or of myself. I probably would be upset too if i was targeted because i was middle eastern to show my id. Suing doesnt erase the horrible images and memory of what happened, as much as persians like to think money can fix everything, he will never be the same again. Noone will, i know i wont and I wasnt even there. what can you "make" out of being tazed and humilated in front of other students in a library?
Comment
-
Originally posted by golgol85 View Posteven if he was being a tough guy, adam ke nakoshte bood ke injoori bahash kardan. Why do we have cops? to protect us, not to harm us, especially when we arent doing anything wrong. I am glad I wasnt there, I dont know what i would have done, but I wouldnt have been able to stand there and watch, this i promise you.
I dont know you well enough to expect anything form you, but I did know you I would expect you to have enough guts to stand up for yourself, thats all i expect of anyone or of myself. I probably would be upset too if i was targeted because i was middle eastern to show my id. Suing doesnt erase the horrible images and memory of what happened, as much as persians like to think money can fix everything, he will never be the same again. Noone will, i know i wont and I wasnt even there. what can you "make" out of being tazed and humilated in front of other students in a library?
oh come on please it was a tazaing
people go throgh some of the same stuff in your avrage hazing
at my firends fertirnity they made the do litly stuff that boarders what they did to that guy
and in regards to what you said
"I wouldnt have been able to stand there and watch, this i promise you."
dont be so sure ofcourse unless you are drawing referance from before
thier have ben were i have seen unjiust actions infront of me and i have been silanced or stayed scinlance i dont think because i was a cowred but at real time in the situation you do what your gut feelings tells you
especialy in that situation did see how the a holes even threatend the students
when i was watching the video i said to mysef if it was me i would push my self and others into the cops
but i dought i would do it
i dono everyone is diffrent
but dont worry about him i am sure his fine
its not like he saw death in the face
you want tramatazing is when guns and shot guns and machin guns are pointed at you all the while the agresor is speaking another language which you dont understand and you at the same time see fear in his eyes because he is also scared of you thats tramatazing not when a cop in tazing you with people watchng and their is communication going on
what happend to me was in israel i was jeruslam in a naiborhood were attacks were common and me and my forends wewre walking when all of a sudden out of nowere this ninja styled motorcycle poped out circled us and than perty much interagated us for a litle than they saw we were americans the just dispiared again
any one know what i am talking about?
they are a special police unit in israel they dress in all black with black motorcycles and german mp5's they are very stealth and agil somwate insane
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
Just cuz people are khar enough to join fraternities, that doesnt mean you can compare the two situations mike. The guys who join fraternities do it of their own free will, they choose to be treated badly. This guy didnt choose to be tazed. I know you might argue that resisting was his choice and with that choice came tazing, in which case inadvertantly he did infact choose to be tazed vali i dont agree. I realize there are consequences for certain actions, but what happened here sounds like something that would happen to student against the government in iran, not something that would happen at a US institution, and UCLA at that.
i dont know if you have realized this by reading my posts, but i am not one to be intimidated very easily. sometimes my kalekharness has gotten me in trouble, but i still choose to share what i think regardless. when my gut says something is wrong, bishtare vaghta i will voice my concern. being able to voice how you feel has nothing to do with being a coward, it has to do with your personality. some people are just more vocal about certain issues than others. you are right, people are different. you tell me the guy brings it upon himself when he refuses to show id, then you are chastising the cops for threatening to tazer the bystanding students. pas ghabool dari ke the cops are wrong and therefore there was no need to tazer? If you say the guy brought it upon himself when he refused, then you have to say the cops are justified in threatening the students who are also interfering with what the cops are doing. The cops were Not justified in anything they did.
hmm, what is this special police unit? I thought you said israel was safe and that the government was nice and yet they harass their own people? I had a pretty interesting happen when i was in iran. I think it was in the airport one of the ladies with chador (the women police makhfi) happened to comment on my hair, which wasnt showing, but she could tell i was foreign so she decided to harass me. Instead of appologizing, i told her that my hair was none of her concern and that she should go tell the girls born and raised in iran to put themselves together and fix their hair, not me (no offense to any of the girls here who are born and raised in iran, i just thought it was unfair they were walking around with arayash and 3/4 of their hair showing and be man band karde bood even though i had no makeup on and my hair was pretty covered). she called over a couple of her sarbaz buddies, it was great i tell you. he asked if there was a problem, i told him no, she is just bothering me about my hair. He mentioned that my hair was fine, then he left, but my mom was really mad at me (she kept telling me to drop it, and i was like nope.). try messing with people in iran, its not any less scary than the special police unit in Israel.
Comment
-
Nilo- don't you wish people would be sincere in their arguments and used logic and evidence for bringing their conclusions forward, especially when we're dealing with serious and human rights issues? What's that saying that there are a few who always hold the good things back or something... I find this truly offending to those who are serious and genuine, as well as those who suffer because of ridiculous arguments. From Bush to people in family and forums, this seems to be the biggest problem for solving today's extreme problems. And its no use talking to these type of people. They don't care about truth. Its about might makes right for them.
Cheers khanum gol...Take him and cut him out in little stars,
and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
that all the world will be in love with night,
and pay no worship to the garish sun
- Shakespeare
"In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill
Comment
-
but see their are times were it is diffrent were you have to drea the line bewtween having choja boodan and just being an idot
if i had wanted to resist their actions mostl likly i would have gotton shot
but see my situation was diffrent the police i dont think he should be called a polic but whatever
i am sure he was more scared of me than i was of him
he realy thogh i might blow my self up or somthin
and my dumbass of a firend he was religious and he would refuse to shave his beard and on top of that he wore a this huge white yamaka that looked like the ones the imams wear (how ironic even physicaly both sides look ike each other) anyways we were in an ultra orthodoz naiborhood were all the people look like pinguens
so we were out of place and the time was wiered to 2 in the morning i dono what a terrorist will blow up or do at 2 in the morning anyways
the police right when they found out we were jewish i am sure it was more jewsih than american they just droped the whole thing they got back on their bickes and just disapiared again
they have really good flash lights to they know how to blined you with it temporarly
see that situation resisting would be stupid becuase ther mentality is protaction of the community
they cann care less if they hurt someone feeling or not or if they infring on your right at the end of the day see nutralizing a risk is more important than risking not to nutralize it
and you know what you did i have to say good job i wouldnt have because i wouldnt know what they would do to me i they could do what ever they want and knowone will know so you really are choja
alos let me say a better situation two
i was walking in the arab quarter me and almost 20 people in my gorup were all of a sudden this palastinian guy provoked this haradi guy (i swear i am not being biased it was like that) so naturaly me and my group even thogh we didnt know what was going on were going to obviously back up the religious jew especialy when you are not using your rational. the rabbais with us started to pull some of us back and pushing us than out of no were i dono how the israelis do this when i say out of no wear i mean it these soldire came went crazy with his words and and foced us in one direction and the arab guy in the other infact they i think escortated were he was going
i swear over their it really is a military state in satin gloves
were the hell does a soldir pop out from
they have cameras every this was in a tunnel not really tunnel underground but like a man madee tunnel
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
joubin you have it wrong these people probably including me get their information throgh experiancesOriginally posted by joubin View PostNilo- don't you wish people would be sincere in their arguments and used logic and evidence for bringing their conclusions forward, especially when we're dealing with serious and human rights issues? What's that saying that there are a few who always hold the good things back or something... I find this truly offending to those who are serious and genuine, as well as those who suffer because of ridiculous arguments. From Bush to people in family and forums, this seems to be the biggest problem for solving today's extreme problems. And its no use talking to these type of people. They don't care about truth. Its about might makes right for them.
Cheers khanum gol...
how can you convince somone of somthing else when he has experianced it
offcourse you probably eventuly can but its very hard
and at the same time what makes the other who hast experianced what they are preaching correct
G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.
Comment
-
experience isn't objective analysis mike. that should be simple enough, yet I don't doubt that somehow you'll twist it around and turn it into a tornado.
Anyway, I didn't come here to get into a tornado. I came to give emotional support to someone who cares, is serious and is not all about the flurry, particularly as she embarks on a classical endless journey. Not that her effort is futile however...Take him and cut him out in little stars,
and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
that all the world will be in love with night,
and pay no worship to the garish sun
- Shakespeare
"In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill
Comment
Comment