"Iranian-American Student Abused

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mike435
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2006
    • 2104

    #91
    Originally posted by joubin View Post
    experience isn't objective analysis mike. that should be simple enough, yet I don't doubt that somehow you'll twist it around and turn it into a tornado.

    offcourse it is not
    but it is more real to the observer than thoghts

    the triangle in my hand is more real than the definition of triangle even thogh the real triangle is the one in the dictionary

    you see what i mean


    G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


    Comment

    • zubin
      Member
      • Aug 2006
      • 1567

      #92
      no. I don't see what you mean and whoever does see it has entered a tornado. objective analysis is objective analysis and is not experience. experience may be related in a very particular way to contributing to objective analysis, but simply "seeing something better" is not objective and in fact can bias the analysis. It is only useful if the person understands that his/her experience, though a valid piece of empirical evidence, does not comprise the whole truth in any way and that they must use an objective framework to understand their experience and use it in analysis and even in their life. Good night.
      Last edited by zubin; 12-01-2006, 10:00 PM.
      Take him and cut him out in little stars,
      and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
      that all the world will be in love with night,
      and pay no worship to the garish sun

      - Shakespeare

      "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

      Comment

      • mike435
        Senior Member
        • Aug 2006
        • 2104

        #93
        listen do you belive in faith

        i think i was destined to see you on this site

        i mean look we both joined aug 06

        in almost every topic we endup going at it
        even thogh the same that i have tired you try to abstain
        or just ignore
        or say this is the last time i talke to him yet agian and again we talek


        G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


        Comment

        • zubin
          Member
          • Aug 2006
          • 1567

          #94
          that's beautiful. I wish it matched your intentions in discussion and analysis and was not deceptive.
          Take him and cut him out in little stars,
          and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
          that all the world will be in love with night,
          and pay no worship to the garish sun

          - Shakespeare

          "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

          Comment

          • mike435
            Senior Member
            • Aug 2006
            • 2104

            #95
            Originally posted by joubin View Post
            no. I don't see what you mean and whoever does see it has entered a tornado.
            look what i am saying is this

            an israeli kid will hate a palastinian after he has blown up his firend because thats all he sees the viciousnes of the palastinian who blew him up that is is experiance slash reality

            he doesnot and cant understand that look the reason your firend got blown up was becuase of xyz call it occupation, brutality, revange, socio economic conditions forcing him etc

            and offcourse this is true vise versa to i just didnt use it the other way becuase you guys would take it as biast and my arguamnt would loose credebility

            this is the same with guy staling from a low income naiborhood

            the rich educated will become racisst becuase his reality and experiance was that of the guy who stole from him

            not that becuase of the messed up community he was put in that postion

            offcourse he the thief is wrong but do you see what i mean now


            G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


            Comment

            • mike435
              Senior Member
              • Aug 2006
              • 2104

              #96
              Originally posted by joubin View Post
              that's beautiful. I wish it matched your intentions in discussion and analysis and was not deceptive.

              if i wanted deception i wouldnt put my self in a defensive situation nor would i keep chanlangning what you say i would just ignore you or beter yet just stop talking

              but i have confidance in my bleifs and i throw them out their and everytime i do i know i might be wrong


              G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


              Comment

              • zubin
                Member
                • Aug 2006
                • 1567

                #97
                Originally posted by mike435 View Post
                look what i am saying is this

                an israeli kid will hate a palastinian after he has blown up his firend because thats all he sees the viciousnes of the palastinian who blew him up that is is experiance slash reality

                he doesnot and cant understand that look the reason your firend got blown up was becuase of xyz call it occupation, brutality, revange, socio economic conditions forcing him etc

                and offcourse this is true vise versa to i just didnt use it the other way becuase you guys would take it as biast and my arguamnt would loose credebility

                this is the same with guy staling from a low income naiborhood

                the rich educated will become racisst becuase his reality and experiance was that of the guy who stole from him

                not that becuase of the messed up community he was put in that postion

                offcourse he the thief is wrong but do you see what i mean now
                BUDDY, you are getting off track and twisting the whole point of my point. I am not talking about this. I stated a fact relevant to the topic. I said that experience is not objective and people should be objective in serious discussion and analysis instead of playing games. We agree with that and that's that. There's no need to bring in the tornado. So whether you were tortured or if you've lived a purely unbiased life, at least when it comes to serious discussion, be objective. If you are not objective in a serious discussion and so are playing games and have your ulterior motor running, you are essentially hurting (and in my opinion offending) the other person you talk to, as well as the very topic. I know its common to do these things, but that doesn't make it any better.

                Clearly I can't interfere with your or others' discussion. I was talking to Nilo and you chose to have this discussion. Now that you would like to have this boring and important discussion, essentially "talking about talking", I thought I should go all out and expose your twister method.
                Last edited by zubin; 12-01-2006, 10:28 PM.
                Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                that all the world will be in love with night,
                and pay no worship to the garish sun

                - Shakespeare

                "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                Comment

                • zubin
                  Member
                  • Aug 2006
                  • 1567

                  #98
                  Originally posted by mike435 View Post
                  if i wanted deception i wouldnt put my self in a defensive situation nor would i keep chanlangning what you say i would just ignore you or beter yet just stop talking
                  i get what you're saying here, but you could still be deceptive by appearing to care about logic and truth, but not really

                  but i have confidance in my bleifs and i throw them out their and everytime i do i know i might be wrong
                  This is the little relief there exists in talking to you, however small it may be. It is also quite rare for someone with your beliefs to actually talk and that's valuable. As you said, they would rather hide and have faith in the power to crush others than talk, though this doesn't rule out that you are deceptive or not.

                  But overall its quite stressful to talk both because its not clear if you really care about what you're saying, seen in that you clearly often twist people's statements and arguments as well as present your views as the ultimate truth without providing any logic or evidence.

                  Again, I'm not saying you should not talk. But since you brought this up with me, I feel free to be frank about the wrongness, even perhaps in terms of ethics, of some forms of discussion, talking and persuasion which you exemplify. Sorry
                  Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                  and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                  that all the world will be in love with night,
                  and pay no worship to the garish sun

                  - Shakespeare

                  "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                  Comment

                  • golgol85
                    Senior Member
                    • Jan 2006
                    • 4957

                    #99
                    Originally posted by joubin View Post
                    Nilo- don't you wish people would be sincere in their arguments and used logic and evidence for bringing their conclusions forward, especially when we're dealing with serious and human rights issues? What's that saying that there are a few who always hold the good things back or something... I find this truly offending to those who are serious and genuine, as well as those who suffer because of ridiculous arguments. From Bush to people in family and forums, this seems to be the biggest problem for solving today's extreme problems. And its no use talking to these type of people. They don't care about truth. Its about might makes right for them.

                    Cheers khanum gol...
                    I think its a good idea to try to lead these people on the right track. Sometimes an idea sounds good in our heads but we cant express it well or back it up with proper evidence. Human rights the word is composed of two words: human and rights. the people who have to give out the rights and uphold them have to be human to understand the importance of those rights, and with the instance that happened I dont consider that officer to be a human. A human can never ever inflict pain when the outcome is not a good one. one could argue that a doctor inflicts pain on a patient when cracking open his ribs to perform open heart surgery to graft new arteries for the ones he clogged eating hambergers and fries everyday for 30 years, but the outcome of the surgery is the man gets to live (eventhough he has to recover from sugery). In the case of this young man, he didnt need to be targeted as a middle eastern to be harassed, he didnt need to be tazed to be reminded he is a middle eastern and as such viewed as a threat. Anyone who has dark hair and looks middle eastern is not a threat, look at Timothy McVeigh he was white and he masterminded the Oklahoma City bombings, which was in itself a terrorist act. Its interesting that the word rights is plural, i would say the most important human righT is to be treated like a human, and yet that very basic right is contantly abused.

                    What I am trying to say is that each person has a truth that they see as their own reality, but sometimes that truth is so far from the reality that its a joke. Some would say leave the person to be in their own world, i say help them realize they are mistaken but let them reevaluate what their truth is on their own.

                    Comment

                    • golgol85
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2006
                      • 4957

                      #100
                      wow guys, az koja be koja raftin. When i made the post above, I hadnt read what you two had been discussing, but I will let you know what I think. First off mike, every thread does not need to go to the Israeli Palestinian issue. I know its important, and I know you care deeply about it (as much as i do or ramin does), but you dont need to bring it in every discussion. we are talking about a man who was targeted because of his middle eastern appearance and was mistreated because of his middle eastern appearance. Racism still exists even in the 21st centry and that is sad, but i have experienced it first hand so i dont feel like this is new news. I asked you about the situation that you encountered because I was curious. Its not a matter of being shoja, you call it being an "idiot" let me tell you that many looked at what rosa parks did as "idiotic", but look at the strides she made for the civil right movement. there will always be those that favor being cautious, but being cautious doesnt do much for a cause. you say its better not to get involved, then you get involved in a fight when you dont even really know what is going on, mike bekhoda nemifahmamet bazi vaghta. inghadr harfat zed o naghiz dareh ke nagoo.

                      Each person's experiences forms the way the person thinks and feels. Obejectivity is usually lost when you bring in personal experience because you only look at the experience from your personal point of view.

                      Comment

                      • zubin
                        Member
                        • Aug 2006
                        • 1567

                        #101
                        What I find interesting about this comment, aside from it hitting the spot, is that I don't think the word 'human' has advanced to the meaning that you portray onto it in the English language and culture (you're a head of the game Nilo ). At least not yet. I mean when we say "adam" and "adami-zad", we're portraying a value to it automatically, its implicit. I can yell and say "man adam hastam!" and it has a meaning of value, but in English saying, "I am a human!" or "I am a human being!", the value content seems to me to be more obscure. I think this stems from the fact that many North American ideologies do not like to attribute values of this sort to humans, and I think this contributes to violation of human rights, or righT, as you cleverly, in I think a very Irani way, put it.


                        Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
                        I think its a good idea to try to lead these people on the right track. Sometimes an idea sounds good in our heads but we cant express it well or back it up with proper evidence. Human rights the word is composed of two words: human and rights. the people who have to give out the rights and uphold them have to be human to understand the importance of those rights, and with the instance that happened I dont consider that officer to be a human. A human can never ever inflict pain when the outcome is not a good one. one could argue that a doctor inflicts pain on a patient when cracking open his ribs to perform open heart surgery to graft new arteries for the ones he clogged eating hambergers and fries everyday for 30 years, but the outcome of the surgery is the man gets to live (eventhough he has to recover from sugery). In the case of this young man, he didnt need to be targeted as a middle eastern to be harassed, he didnt need to be tazed to be reminded he is a middle eastern and as such viewed as a threat. Anyone who has dark hair and looks middle eastern is not a threat, look at Timothy McVeigh he was white and he masterminded the Oklahoma City bombings, which was in itself a terrorist act. Its interesting that the word rights is plural, i would say the most important human righT is to be treated like a human, and yet that very basic right is contantly abused.

                        What I am trying to say is that each person has a truth that they see as their own reality, but sometimes that truth is so far from the reality that its a joke. Some would say leave the person to be in their own world, i say help them realize they are mistaken but let them reevaluate what their truth is on their own.
                        Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                        and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                        that all the world will be in love with night,
                        and pay no worship to the garish sun

                        - Shakespeare

                        "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                        Comment

                        • mike435
                          Senior Member
                          • Aug 2006
                          • 2104

                          #102
                          Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
                          inghadr harfat zed o naghiz dareh ke nagoo.

                          Each person's experiences forms the way the person thinks and feels. Obejectivity is usually lost when you bring in personal experience because you only look at the experience from your personal point of view.

                          what does that mean zed o naghiz what is naghiz


                          i really liked what you said
                          and that what i mean but see the thing is many times it is the experiance that lets to ones gut feeling and in a situation when you cant think gut feeling rules becuase as you said gut feeling bypasses prejudic

                          and israeli palastinian yea i knoe khodamam kheili lajam migere but i guss it was the only thing the i could draw on as an example


                          G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                          Comment

                          • Nutcase
                            Member
                            • Jan 2006
                            • 830

                            #103
                            mike, golgol and jubin, u 3 have all valid points, now kiss and make up already, if there are some views that u guys don't share, its no big deal, listen if we would all be the same, we would not be able to have such lively discussions, thats the very foundation of what makes us think and act. now plz someone tell me, since mustafa has taken a certain police officer to court, has any justice been served, is the trial going on? whats happening on this regard? thx cheers

                            Comment

                            • zubin
                              Member
                              • Aug 2006
                              • 1567

                              #104
                              Originally posted by Nutcase View Post
                              mike, golgol and jubin, u 3 have all valid points, now kiss and make up already, if there are some views that u guys don't share, its no big deal, listen if we would all be the same, we would not be able to have such lively discussions, thats the very foundation of what makes us think and act. now plz someone tell me, since mustafa has taken a certain police officer to court, has any justice been served, is the trial going on? whats happening on this regard? thx cheers
                              You're making a false assumption about my thoughts. My disagreement with mike isn't about his views. Plus, mike, golgol and I are adults and can manage our discussions. They never get out of hand. Mike even enjoys his rival discussions with me (though to be frank I don't enjoy them too much, but this doesn't mean that they are even close to out of hand in the way that you are assuming). On the other hand, an alternative view would perhaps be useful and add to the conversation.

                              I recommend that you look more into the context of our discussion so there aren't any misunderstandings. I could look at middle of someone's discussion when they call you "bozo", but then find out that this was meant as a harmless joke when put in context. There is a similar misunderstanding here.

                              Updates are frequently provided on this thread. I'm sure someone will continue to provide them (I think IQ). In any case, our discussion was also relevant as it was regarding whether Mr. Mustafa was to blame for what happened to him or not, and what types of justifications can be provided for such a claim. It's a discussion about the incident. Unless I'm inherently delusional or something, I think this is a discussion board in addition to a media resource. It's just that, when having a discussion, there are certain ethics that some people do not abide by to the detriment of everyone. But this is itself a discussion point and I'm not saying such ethics should be enforced.

                              Please clarify if I'm misunderstanding something here, and best wishes.
                              Last edited by zubin; 12-02-2006, 07:03 PM.
                              Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                              and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                              that all the world will be in love with night,
                              and pay no worship to the garish sun

                              - Shakespeare

                              "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                              Comment

                              • mike435
                                Senior Member
                                • Aug 2006
                                • 2104

                                #105
                                i spite og golgols comment i ahve to say i think it was bothere faults

                                we shouldnt just blame the cop


                                G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                                Comment

                                Working...