"Iranian-American Student Abused

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • golgol85
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2006
    • 4957

    #121
    Originally posted by mike435 View Post
    listen in my hearts of hearts i still dont belive they trageted him becuase he was middleeater
    on what basis he might blow up the library
    to take reveng on him becuase of current day stuff
    i dout it man i really do

    i know so many people who go theri all the time i am not a stufdent and i go their

    shit i bet a huge percentage are persian in my sis's chem class almost the whole class is persian

    i
    well, your opinion is valid for you, but i have to let the facts speak. the cop in question shot a homeless man, he tazed a fraternity brother, he is just generally sick. He wouldnt care who he is dealing with, he would act with brutality regardless, but if you for one second think that if mostafa was white with blond hair he wouldnt have been treated differently you are kidding yourself. People base their opinions not only on their personal experiences, but also on the news and other people's experiences. why do you think some muslims who have never even interacted with jews dislike them with such a passion? They base their thoughts on the news, on what they HEAR, not on experience. I personally dont agree with this method, i like to try things out for myself and in this particular matter i have to say some of my closest friends have been jewish and the muslim jewish issue has never dampened our friendship, whether the person was a persian jew or non persian jew.

    Lots of people go there you are right, but not everyone is Terrece Dueren. I know so many persians at UCLA, from undergrads to MD/PHD's to masters students. all of them voice concern after this incident, that they feel that their middle eastern appearance could cause them to be singled out. Its not a good time to be a middle eastern, in any part of the world, from any walk of life you are from.

    Comment

    • golgol85
      Senior Member
      • Jan 2006
      • 4957

      #122
      Originally posted by mike435 View Post
      wow thats crazy what happend

      but honestly you should expect some of that even thogh its wrong
      becuase look many americans feel as if they were taken advantage of for being plurist.
      best example they compare theme selfs with israel were over their they practice insane ratial profiling and they have a much better trak record of protecting everyone.
      wiw reading the second post i can see what you mean with "new blacks"
      i think your right but than right when i say that all the diffrent imagas of what they did to the blacks flashes in my head and it out ways whats happening tremandisly
      can we say than on a micro level middle easterners are being treated unequaly.
      see theirs the filter again
      even thogh i thoght i experiance it i dont

      I am sorry, i shouldnt expect any such treatment. I was born and raised here just like any other white kid, if you were to hear me speak over the phone you wouldnt be able to tell i am persian. As for when i speak farsi, bazam i speak farsi well enough where most people are surprized i was born and raised here. I did not take advantage of anyone and i wont let anyone take advantage of me. There has to be some difference between here and iran and the way you are dealt with.

      I dont think you really follow the news mike, please inform yourself more of how muslims are treated and then come to me and say i am drawing a false parallel between the treatment of blacks pre civil war and the treatment of mulsims post september 11th. Just take a look right after september 11th and how many muslims were targeted and murdered here in the US. You seem to make racial profiling seem like a petty nuisance, but its a matter of dignity and respect. There is more to it than just being searched.

      You are jewish, please dont compare yourself to a muslim. You said yourself your star of david got you to be treated differently in an airport. You cant even imagine for one second how it must feel for those who are really singled out.

      Comment

      • mike435
        Senior Member
        • Aug 2006
        • 2104

        #123
        Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
        You cant even imagine for one second how it must feel for those who are really singled out.
        you are in for surprise
        have you ever been accepted into a social circle as one identity
        and then fined out that people closest to your close friend hate your other identity that they dont know about based on nothing
        that is what i call being single out




        but yea i see what you mean
        maybe it is becuase i am so used to a diffrent treatment tht it has bexoe a norm


        and considering antisemitisom
        i dono i think thats a force all of its own

        and considering muslim suffrage in american socioty i dont think it comes even close to anything of what has happend to so many other people probably becuase this might be the begenning of it and peobably it wil get worse

        you know carlos mencia said it best in one joke

        it went somthing like this
        the day the planes hit the towers
        "lacishia, maria, jose and tyron went to akhmad and said your it"
        Last edited by mike435; 12-09-2006, 05:59 PM.


        G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


        Comment

        • nedamm
          Member
          • Jan 2006
          • 50

          #124

          Comment

          • nedamm
            Member
            • Jan 2006
            • 50

            #125

            Comment

            • zubin
              Member
              • Aug 2006
              • 1567

              #126
              Originally posted by mike435 View Post
              jubin goggol read some of kants and werhans writings i think they very nicly pertymuch take everything we said here about interpatations of reality and put it in a nice step by step idea.

              the reading i read were from a bussiness ethics book
              Hi Mike. How are you doing?

              In response to this comment, I have something to say. It's very interesting to read many of these philosophers and theorists in the world in general. The thing is that many of their ideas are wrong, or are only partially true. One of Marx's many views was to hear what a philosopher has to say and then "change it".

              Regarding Kant, there are many, many, an almost infinite amount of criticisms that exist today. There are also many logical reasons for why what some of what he said seems far stronger than others in its assumptions about human beings, human psychology, and so forth. That's why I would like to ask if you could explain which specific one of Kant's views you think is gold. If I have dealt with it before, I'll let you know what I found the problem or assumption in his argument to be if any.

              Then the next thing is to apply it to the current discussion which I think you wanted to do.

              Ramin



              Last edited by zubin; 12-09-2006, 08:44 PM.
              Take him and cut him out in little stars,
              and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
              that all the world will be in love with night,
              and pay no worship to the garish sun

              - Shakespeare

              "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

              Comment

              • mike435
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2006
                • 2104

                #127
                Originally posted by joubin View Post
                Hi Mike. How are you doing?

                In response to this comment, I have something to say. It's very interesting to read many of these philosophers and theorists in the world in general. The thing is that many of their ideas are wrong, or are only partially true. One of Marx's many views was to hear what a philosopher has to say and then "change it".

                Regarding Kant, there are many, many, an almost infinite amount of criticisms that exist today. There are also many logical reasons for why what some of what he said seems far stronger than others in its assumptions about human beings, human psychology, and so forth. That's why I would like to ask if you could explain which specific one of Kant's views you think is gold. If I have dealt with it before, I'll let you know what I found the problem or assumption in his argument to be if any.

                Then the next thing is to apply it to the current discussion which I think you wanted to do.

                Ramin



                i think one of the best and golden ideas from kant is veil of ignorance

                offcourse you can never apply it but i think if you have enogh people even a litle trying to wear the veil of ignorance when making decions we have accomplished alot


                G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                Comment

                • zubin
                  Member
                  • Aug 2006
                  • 1567

                  #128
                  Wasn't that Rawls? But anyway, what is the veil of ignorance in your opinion?
                  Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                  and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                  that all the world will be in love with night,
                  and pay no worship to the garish sun

                  - Shakespeare

                  "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                  Comment

                  • mike435
                    Senior Member
                    • Aug 2006
                    • 2104

                    #129
                    Originally posted by joubin View Post
                    Wasn't that Rawls? But anyway, what is the veil of ignorance in your opinion?

                    oh yea

                    yea
                    my bad i confused the too

                    veil of ignorance
                    when you make decition with out your own contex of thinking
                    you make it not knowing who you are
                    so you have to make a decion that is fair for everyone
                    because you dont

                    and for kant yea i didnt fined that many out stading things


                    G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                    Comment

                    • zubin
                      Member
                      • Aug 2006
                      • 1567

                      #130
                      Interesting, thanks. My view on Kant is that he is partly good and partly evil. His theory of retributive justice in fact I think is a sickness on the world right now, but perhaps that's for a different thread. Does the veil of ignorance relate to this thread?

                      Khodafez felan.
                      Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                      and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                      that all the world will be in love with night,
                      and pay no worship to the garish sun

                      - Shakespeare

                      "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                      Comment

                      • mike435
                        Senior Member
                        • Aug 2006
                        • 2104

                        #131
                        offcourse it does

                        if for wxample i was wearing the veil of ignorance or forthat matter anyone else you would make decions that you know it could posibliy affect your well being wether it be the officer or the studnt
                        since i dont know who i am i am forced to make a decion that i can live with wether i am the officer or the student

                        OMG RAMIN I JUST NOTICED WHATS WRONG WITH VEIL OF IGNORANCE
                        WOW MAN PERSUING A SUBJECT A BIT OUT OF ITS SHELL IS SO AMAZING

                        what do you think about the veil


                        G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                        Comment

                        • mike435
                          Senior Member
                          • Aug 2006
                          • 2104

                          #132
                          nevermined it is still good


                          G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                          Comment

                          • zubin
                            Member
                            • Aug 2006
                            • 1567

                            #133
                            Haha. Well I definately don't think it says anything on the moral argument being made here against the police officer or Mr. Mustafa. It seems like a good way of putting yourself in someone else's shoes who is less fortunate. I think it is essentially saying if you had to choose what rights you should be entitled to, without having the privileges that you have, what rights would you want for yourself? Then this reveals how a state in all fairness and honesty should provide economic rights to its citizens.
                            Take him and cut him out in little stars,
                            and he will make the face of heaven so fine,
                            that all the world will be in love with night,
                            and pay no worship to the garish sun

                            - Shakespeare

                            "In all intellectual debates, both sides tend to be correct in what they affirm, and wrong in what they deny." - JS Mill

                            Comment

                            • golgol85
                              Senior Member
                              • Jan 2006
                              • 4957

                              #134
                              I think each and every person has a veil of ignorance to some extent, it only depends on how much the person tries to educate themself and look at situations from varying perspectives that the veil is lifted a bit for each person specifically.

                              Mike, being singled out entails people making false assumptions. If for example someone hated you just because you were jewish and they heard a story about one bad jewish man and then the person decided to beat you up because you had a star of david, that would mean you are being singled out. Its not fair and its not practical. I cant base my decisions on others biases. I need to try to objectively view things, and I think i may have been flawed myself in the way i chose to view this issue. I stil dont agree with you, but the premise i base my ideas on has changed.

                              The fact that mostafa was racially targeted or profiled can never be proven. If Terrence Dueren did in fact pick a fight with him because he was Iranian (not because he looked middle eastern) we will never know since we will never know his inner thoughts. I cant therefore say that Terrence Dueren racially targeted Mostafa. I can however say that excessive force was used. Why was this excessive force used? When people are fearful, they use whatever measure or tactic to "instill and enforce peace". After september 11th, the US is fearful of terrorists or anything that appears to appear terrorist related. The cop was fearful, so he used force. The fear does not justify the force, but the democratic system does allow for retribution. Mostafa has the right to have his case tried and Terrence Dueren will most likely lose his job for his actions. At least in the US, if something of this nature happens, there is a chance for retribution where as if something like this had happened in Iran the student would probably be executed. Although its sad that something like this happened to an Iranian, i think the more important thing is that something like this happened to a human. I asked myself if i am this passionate about this to sit here and post so many times in this thread when this situation is related to an Iranian, would i feel the same if it was someone of another minority? I responded yes, i would feel just as strongly but i am sure many in the Iranian community wouldnt give a rat's *** if this had happened to an mexican. Suprizing for me was that many of those that turned out at the protest on the friday after the incident were not Iranian. I really think as a society, we need to stop feeling so defensive.

                              Comment

                              • mike435
                                Senior Member
                                • Aug 2006
                                • 2104

                                #135
                                golgol i do thin you cae about the right treatment of a human regarless of what ever "race", color, religion, sex, orientation etc....

                                but i do belive that the reason you are writing about moustafa and not say the black teen who was abused by this persian officer capole of years ago is becuase the iranian student directly affects you, you share the same frame of refrance as the black teen and mustafa except with him it is much more closer becuase he is persian

                                their have been manyother miss treatments by the police done against other minoroties we dont write about those and it is not becuase we dont care but becuase it is for some reason furthure from us

                                best example is the dufur genocide going on by arab militias
                                the world dosent care, sorrry to bring the palastinian israeli situation only thing i can draw from
                                look 19+ people innocent people died becuase of IDF mistake the world cared enogh to imediatly condem israel and pass resloution and call it a massacare
                                in darfur hundreds of thousends have died annan refuses to call it a genocide infact the world refuses to act on it
                                are the people in darfur less human than in the middle no
                                it just they are not close to us
                                i mean i am most likely gonne go to this concert that will rais money for darfur but that is probably the most i will contribute
                                you guys dont see me opening up post and defending the rights or those people

                                also another reason for writing about moustafa is becuase no one else will and as a fellow iranian you see it necesary to bring the voice of your fellow human out


                                G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                                Comment

                                Working...