"Iranian-American Student Abused

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • donsaeid
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2005
    • 28300

    #106
    كاردار سوئيس در تهران به وزارت خارجه احضار شد


    در پي، پيگيرها در خصوص استيفاي حقوق دانشجوي ايراني در كاليفرنيا كاردار سفارت سوئيس در تهران به وزارت خارجه كشورمان احضار شد.



    به نقل از اداره كل اطلاعات و مطبوعات وزارت خارجه، در چارچوب پيگيري*هاي موثر در خصوص استيفاي حقوق «مصطفي طباطبايي نژاد» دانشجوي ايراني دانشگاه كاليفرنيا، رئيس اداره اول آمريكاي وزارت خارجه كشورمان با احضار كاردار سفارت سوئيس در تهران (در غياب سفير) مراتب اعتراض دولت جمهوري اسلامي ايران را به اين اقدام اعلام كرد.

    علي اكبر رضايي در اين ديدار از «پي*ير ايوفوكس» كاردار سفارت سوئيس خواست تا پس از ابلاغ اعتراض جمهوري اسلامي ايران به مقامات ذيربط دولت آمريكا، وزارت خارجه كشورمان را از نتيجه اقدامات به عمل آمده نسبت به نامبرده مطلع كند.

    لازم به ذكر است سخنگوي وزارت خارجه كشورمان نيز همزمان با ضرب و شتم طباطبايي نژاد در تاريخ 28 آبان ماه سالجاري اقدام پليس آمريكا را به شدت محكوم و بر دفاع از منافع و حقوق اتباع ايران در اقصي نقاط جهان تاكيد ورزيده بود.
    نه غزه نه لبنان جانم فدای ایران


    «در زندگی زخم*هايی هست که مثل خوره روح را آهسته در انزوا می*خورد و می*تراشد.»
    صادق هدايت؛ بوف کور

    Comment

    • mike435
      Senior Member
      • Aug 2006
      • 2104

      #107
      jubin goggol read some of kants and werhans writings i think they very nicly pertymuch take everything we said here about interpatations of reality and put it in a nice step by step idea.

      the reading i read were from a bussiness ethics book


      G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


      Comment

      • Sepideh_UK
        Senior Member
        • May 2006
        • 2226

        #108
        chi shod kholase sarneveshte in pesare?


        Comment

        • golgol85
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2006
          • 4957

          #109
          Mike: zed o naghiz means that you are contradicting yourself. you are an interesting character, i am sure that you get that a lot. I still dont agree when you say you think it is both their faults and this is why. In any situation, one person plays the victim and one the perpetrator of crime. You can have some cases where some will have a difficult time deciding who is who, but this case has clear lines as to who is at fault. Fault can be determined by who harmed who. Did the student harm anyone? Did he threaten anyone? Did he disrupt anyone? The answer to all of these questions is no. Until he was provoked he did nothing. he was just like me or any other university student studying in the library late at night. Did the cops harm him? YES. Did they disrupt anyone? Yes, they not only disrupted the student, but rather they disturbed all who were in the library and witnessed this act. Did the cops threaten anyone? Yes, him and everyone else who thought what was happening was wrong. so you see mike, there is a clear bad guy good guy here. The cops were bad and the student good. If he had taken out a knife, if he had been on a terror promoting site looking up how to make a bomb, even if he had been watching porn like my experience mentioned earlier, they could have had grounds for saying he was threatening or a disruption and they could have asked him to leave.

          I think your misconception comes from the fact that you think all cops are good and all governmental authority is right and just. Reevaluate that you you just might agree with me that the student didnt have any fault in this case.

          Comment

          • golgol85
            Senior Member
            • Jan 2006
            • 4957

            #110
            Originally posted by Nutcase View Post
            mike, golgol and jubin, u 3 have all valid points, now kiss and make up already, if there are some views that u guys don't share, its no big deal, listen if we would all be the same, we would not be able to have such lively discussions, thats the very foundation of what makes us think and act. now plz someone tell me, since mustafa has taken a certain police officer to court, has any justice been served, is the trial going on? whats happening on this regard? thx cheers
            Hi Nooshin joon! Sorry i havent been on, otherwise i would have assured you that we are not arguing maliciously. The three of us have been sharing ideas in various threads and we are fine Thanks for your concern though As for what is happening, i havent heard much other than he is planning to file a federal civil rights lawsuit accusing the UCLA police of "brutal excessive force," as well as false arrest. I'll let you know as soon as i hear anything on this side of the world, although some searching made me very upset. There are some flat out rednecks out there with stuff on their sites that made me want to scream. It seems as middle easterns, we are the new blacks (sorry for not being PC, african american doesnt work in this context) and the klu klux klan still does exist.

            If you have the time, take a look at these sites:
            http://www.gifthub.org/2006/11/mostafa_tabatab.html
            http://www.thehappytutor.com/2006/11...a_tabatab.html
            http://www.thehappytutor.com/2006/11...tabatab_2.html

            Even if these are jokes, I am NOT laughing.

            Comment

            • mike435
              Senior Member
              • Aug 2006
              • 2104

              #111
              Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
              Mike: zed o naghiz means that you are contradicting yourself. you are an interesting character, i am sure that you get that a lot. I still dont agree when you say you think it is both their faults and this is why. In any situation, one person plays the victim and one the perpetrator of crime. You can have some cases where some will have a difficult time deciding who is who, but this case has clear lines as to who is at fault. Fault can be determined by who harmed who. Did the student harm anyone? Did he threaten anyone? Did he disrupt anyone? The answer to all of these questions is no. Until he was provoked he did nothing. he was just like me or any other university student studying in the library late at night. Did the cops harm him? YES. Did they disrupt anyone? Yes, they not only disrupted the student, but rather they disturbed all who were in the library and witnessed this act. Did the cops threaten anyone? Yes, him and everyone else who thought what was happening was wrong. so you see mike, there is a clear bad guy good guy here. The cops were bad and the student good. If he had taken out a knife, if he had been on a terror promoting site looking up how to make a bomb, even if he had been watching porn like my experience mentioned earlier, they could have had grounds for saying he was threatening or a disruption and they could have asked him to leave.

              I think your misconception comes from the fact that you think all cops are good and all governmental authority is right and just. Reevaluate that you you just might agree with me that the student didnt have any fault in this case.
              no i do not think that all cops are good and all authority is good or right
              but i do think that being objactive and seeking the truth means looking at both sides with out prejudice wether one is strong or weaker wether one is dominant or the victom wether one is agreesor or not

              i also dont think that thier is clear worng or correct
              maybe the cop is an enforcer of someone elses idea(thene is the cop at fault), maybe the student passivly disobeyed rules wether fair or not, maybe the cop based on his frame of refrance thoght the student to be a danger and was trying to porform his duty of keeping everyone safe , maybe the student world view told him the right thing to do is fighting injustice(this case showing id) by disobeying,
              you see their is no clear victom and no clear agresor
              i do belive that we all see things throgh diffrent filters
              and all the filters that we have are made up of our experiances, logic, stories, belifs, and knowledge.
              it is these filters that recunstruct an occurance and present it to me in a way that will be diffrent from a way that you see it.
              the question is whos filter is the correct one? whos filter is supirior to another? whos filter should we take in to concideration? or shoul all filters be correct at the smame time but how can that be? or should we be constanly changing filters becuase theri is one absolute filter and we are allways in the persute of that absolute filter


              my responce to this would be
              either make everyone or force upon every one one commen set belif idiology, filter
              or do what kant says and force everyone to start from a veil of ignorance.

              i also belive that the tragedy of beign politicly correct, is that people think the weaker is allways the victom which i think this is wrong,
              i think we should look at both sides regardless of our prejudice IE>vail of ignorance.

              you can also continue and defend the cops action by saying that what he did was right becuase the student disobeyed and was warrned numerous times to obey. and that is why it is the students falt (even thogh i dont agree with this defense)

              iyou can also or should look and see why arnt other students being harrased
              for the fact i have been asked to leav the library befor for not having an id and i gotup and walked out that is one rule of the library.

              i think again both were at fault
              student for disobaying the rule
              cop for using excesisv force or better answer uneccery force

              and puerly from a legal point of view
              we have to see when a cop can or canot use a tazer. and legal does not mean right or ethical or human


              G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


              Comment

              • mike435
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2006
                • 2104

                #112
                Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
                Hi Nooshin joon! Sorry i havent been on, otherwise i would have assured you that we are not arguing maliciously. The three of us have been sharing ideas in various threads and we are fine Thanks for your concern though As for what is happening, i havent heard much other than he is planning to file a federal civil rights lawsuit accusing the UCLA police of "brutal excessive force," as well as false arrest. I'll let you know as soon as i hear anything on this side of the world, although some searching made me very upset. There are some flat out rednecks out there with stuff on their sites that made me want to scream. It seems as middle easterns, we are the new blacks (sorry for not being PC, african american doesnt work in this context) and the klu klux klan still does exist.

                If you have the time, take a look at these sites:
                http://www.gifthub.org/2006/11/mostafa_tabatab.html
                http://www.thehappytutor.com/2006/11...a_tabatab.html
                http://www.thehappytutor.com/2006/11...tabatab_2.html

                Even if these are jokes, I am NOT laughing.
                gogol pleas be very careful on you use of new blacks
                i think by you saying that you are desecrating the black peoples experiance which is nothing like what happedn and what is happening
                this is one incodent that some belive it was right because of prejudic belifs like the redneks
                but dont copare it to the african american suffrage


                G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                Comment

                • golgol85
                  Senior Member
                  • Jan 2006
                  • 4957

                  #113
                  Originally posted by mike435 View Post
                  gogol pleas be very careful on you use of new blacks
                  i think by you saying that you are desecrating the black peoples experiance which is nothing like what happedn and what is happening
                  this is one incodent that some belive it was right because of prejudic belifs like the redneks
                  but dont copare it to the african american suffrage
                  You cant be serious. First off, if you read my post properly, i appologized for using the word black, but african american made no logical sense with my arguement. I am in no way desecrating the black people's experience, i am drawing a parallel between them and us. I am not talking about the tabatabainejad incident as a single incident that is similar to the ENTIRE african american experience throughout histotry, i am using it as ONE example of many infringement of rights for muslims and middle easterns based on appearance and religion. No on who is human can think that what happened to the african americans was right, the only people who believe it is okay to treat someone badly because of color, race, or religion are incompetent and uneducated pigs (valla khooka sharaf daran be baziha ke esmeshoon ro mizaran Adam).

                  What if i said this is similar to the holocast, that there is an ethnic cleansing that has been and will continue to go on from the time september 11th happened till when the United States feels the threat of "terrorists" or better said "muslims and middle easterns" is erradicated? are you going to sit here and tell me that i am wrong in comparing the two? why are you hiding yourself from the truth of the matter that as middle easterns we are under scrunity for no other reason than being middle eastern? I know you might not feel as offended by what is going on because you are jewish, but you are still iranian, and as an iranian you do count as a middle eastern. As a middle eastern, you probably look middle eastern, which means you could be mistaken for a muslim just based on your looks.

                  I read somewhere on facebook in one of the many groups that have formed in an argument that tabatabainejad was Baha'i, which is erroneous since "tabatabainejad" is a muslim last name, in fact he is a "seyed" (decendents of the prophet). let suppose he was Baha'i, do you think it would have made the police act differently if they knew he wasnt? who really cares what religion he has, whether he is jewish, muslim, baha'i or even if he is atheist. the point is he is human, he may have refused to leave but he was defending his rights. In an article in another thread explaining the holcast, it says that the jewish population persisted because of their spirit and zest for life and wanting to live. Look at what tabatabainejad did as his little step in proving to the world that middle easterns and muslims wont succumb and they do want to live.

                  Comment

                  • golgol85
                    Senior Member
                    • Jan 2006
                    • 4957

                    #114
                    You tell me to look without being prejudiced and biased and yet you seem to be set in your thinking. I on the other hand have pondered both sides and find that what the cops did is wrong. More often than not i have seen cops do wrong, like the cop that shot a groom at a club recently. There are plenty of police brutality cases because one of the things that makes a cop have that certain "jazabeh" of seeming powerful is being brutal in some cases. The whole big ego gets to their heads sometimes though.

                    laws govern humans, so they have to be ethical and humane. Mesle ine begam the law says that if i dont like mike's response then i can cut off his fingers so he cant type anymore. the law gives me the authority even though what i am doing as punishment is not humane or ethical. Mike and I can disagree and still be nice to eachother without the use of scare tactics such as cutting off fingers. I am not saying all laws ARE ethical and humane, but they should try to be as humane as possible since the laws are governing humans.

                    you knew what you were doing was wrong: that you were using a UCLA facility for students even though you were not a student there and so you felt obligated to leave when asked. He was a student, so he thought it was okay to be there. He also felt that he was targeted specifically, which i am sure he was.

                    let me give you an example of what i have experienced: The muslim student group had a meeting to protest against a lecturer who was displaying the caricatures drawn of mohammad and both the jews and the muslims came out to protest. I was in the parking lot across from the building this was happening in with my iranian friend. As we got out of her car, I noticed there was a swat team special agent looking cop standing with a huge vicious dog. I had been talking in farsi, and as we approached the stairs to exit the parking lot, he gave me a very nasty and cold stare and had the dog pointed in my direction, in a sense he made the dog come in my direction and sniff close to me. Now tell me that had nothing to do with the fact ke ghiyafam dad mizaneh irooni hastam. Its racial profiling, since if i was blond with blue eyes they man would have never done that. I was so tempted to talk back to him, but i was worried he would let the dog loose on me and I didnt want to be attacked by the dog.

                    no one has a perfect filter, but sometimes we need to acknowledge the fact that our filter may not work too well and we may be biased. I still cant understand why you would even for one second defend the cop, but i respect your ideas.
                    Mike the world we live in is not pretty. I know you would like to think that there is no black and white when it comes to gulity and not guilty, but normally there is no grey area either.

                    Comment

                    • Nutcase
                      Member
                      • Jan 2006
                      • 830

                      #115
                      i have not been updating myself on this topic, because it is truly disturbing to me, i get emotional and take this issue very personal, meaning they may have tazed me. thx 2 all 3 of u 4 the clarifications, yes nowadays it seems that racism is more clear on the middle eastern people than african americans. nevermind what religion mustafa is, the point is, once the police found out he is persian, that was enough 4 them and since we all know how dumb most americans are, they think that all persians and middle eastern people have to be muslim, which is bogus. but then again they eat up what the media feeds them, cause their lazy asses will not do their own research. this is so incredibly frustrating this whole mess, all i know is i am counting my blessings every day that i don't live in the country below me, the horror, the nightmare, the greatest country in the world? my ***! excuse the lingo, but i am so fed up, khob asabam khurd shod, i better sleep on this one, i'm out 4 now. peace!

                      Comment

                      • golgol85
                        Senior Member
                        • Jan 2006
                        • 4957

                        #116
                        i completely agree with you, but to think that things like this only happen in the US is a joke. It happens everywhere, its just we get horrified when something like this happens in the US since we expect the US to be a role model in its behavior toward foreigners. No country is perfect, that is the reality. I really have been very upset about this issue myself nooshin joon, asabam ro hessabi beham rikht az vaghti ke fahmidam. Imagine being a student at a UC campus knowing that we have UCPD too. Onvaghte ke vaghti mishinam toyeh library minevisam vasatoon inja tamame badanam moor moor mishe thinking that he was doing what i was doing, working on a comp in the library. the best way to combat ignorance is through education. We need to know what is going on in the world, even if we cant change things that are happening.

                        Comment

                        • Nutcase
                          Member
                          • Jan 2006
                          • 830

                          #117
                          that is true, awareness is an important part in understanding what is going on around us, even though we may not be able to help or directly affect the situation at hand everytime. by the way when i am frustrated at the US, its not just on this issue, i am talking about the whole picture, of course many countries have their own troubles, but boy it seems like the US stands out like an eyesore, they are instigators and bullies, and make the rest of the world look like the devils, when they start the fire, i mean who put khomeini in power? who bombed nagasaki and hiroshima? who sold WMDs to saddam hussein in the 80ies? yeah the list goes on but i think one gets the picture.

                          Comment

                          • mike435
                            Senior Member
                            • Aug 2006
                            • 2104

                            #118
                            Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
                            You cant be serious. First off, if you read my post properly, i appologized for using the word black, but african american made no logical sense with my arguement. I am in no way desecrating the black people's experience, i am drawing a parallel between them and us. I am not talking about the tabatabainejad incident as a single incident that is similar to the ENTIRE african american experience throughout histotry, i am using it as ONE example of many infringement of rights for muslims and middle easterns based on appearance and religion. No on who is human can think that what happened to the african americans was right, the only people who believe it is okay to treat someone badly because of color, race, or religion are incompetent and uneducated pigs (valla khooka sharaf daran be baziha ke esmeshoon ro mizaran Adam).

                            What if i said this is similar to the holocast, that there is an ethnic cleansing that has been and will continue to go on from the time september 11th happened till when the United States feels the threat of "terrorists" or better said "muslims and middle easterns" is erradicated? are you going to sit here and tell me that i am wrong in comparing the two? why are you hiding yourself from the truth of the matter that as middle easterns we are under scrunity for no other reason than being middle eastern? I know you might not feel as offended by what is going on because you are jewish, but you are still iranian, and as an iranian you do count as a middle eastern. As a middle eastern, you probably look middle eastern, which means you could be mistaken for a muslim just based on your looks.

                            I read somewhere on facebook in one of the many groups that have formed in an argument that tabatabainejad was Baha'i, which is erroneous since "tabatabainejad" is a muslim last name, in fact he is a "seyed" (decendents of the prophet). let suppose he was Baha'i, do you think it would have made the police act differently if they knew he wasnt? who really cares what religion he has, whether he is jewish, muslim, baha'i or even if he is atheist. the point is he is human, he may have refused to leave but he was defending his rights. In an article in another thread explaining the holcast, it says that the jewish population persisted because of their spirit and zest for life and wanting to live. Look at what tabatabainejad did as his little step in proving to the world that middle easterns and muslims wont succumb and they do want to live.
                            ok you are taking what i said the wrong what i said was even drawing pararels is desecration because the blacks african american whaterver they ent trogh alot worse

                            i dont think you can even compare it i mean what happens here we just get stoped at airport and stuff like that

                            also keep in mined
                            i myself dont feel that much of a diffrance in treatment
                            plus unless being jewish dosent take away from my middle eastern apearance
                            but i have to be hones thogh when i was at the airport changing flights in canda i was "randomly" selected and right when the guy saw my star of david neckless he didnt even care about the search anymore
                            liek he just cared because he had started it and didnt want to make it obvious

                            also tell you the truth concidering all things going around i dont see a problam with ratial profiling if done the right way.

                            and right now its acctualy hot to be muslim or middleeastern because the schools want to show off that
                            are diverse and politicaly correct

                            i still think middle eastern treatment is nothing compared to the treatment of blacks considering civilrights

                            by the way i just read your second post this post doesnt take into considiration your second post
                            Last edited by mike435; 12-07-2006, 11:19 PM.


                            G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                            Comment

                            • mike435
                              Senior Member
                              • Aug 2006
                              • 2104

                              #119
                              Originally posted by golgol85 View Post
                              You tell me to look without being prejudiced and biased and yet you seem to be set in your thinking. I on the other hand have pondered both sides and find that what the cops did is wrong. More often than not i have seen cops do wrong, like the cop that shot a groom at a club recently. There are plenty of police brutality cases because one of the things that makes a cop have that certain "jazabeh" of seeming powerful is being brutal in some cases. The whole big ego gets to their heads sometimes though.

                              laws govern humans, so they have to be ethical and humane. Mesle ine begam the law says that if i dont like mike's response then i can cut off his fingers so he cant type anymore. the law gives me the authority even though what i am doing as punishment is not humane or ethical. Mike and I can disagree and still be nice to eachother without the use of scare tactics such as cutting off fingers. I am not saying all laws ARE ethical and humane, but they should try to be as humane as possible since the laws are governing humans.

                              you knew what you were doing was wrong: that you were using a UCLA facility for students even though you were not a student there and so you felt obligated to leave when asked. He was a student, so he thought it was okay to be there. He also felt that he was targeted specifically, which i am sure he was.

                              let me give you an example of what i have experienced: The muslim student group had a meeting to protest against a lecturer who was displaying the caricatures drawn of mohammad and both the jews and the muslims came out to protest. I was in the parking lot across from the building this was happening in with my iranian friend. As we got out of her car, I noticed there was a swat team special agent looking cop standing with a huge vicious dog. I had been talking in farsi, and as we approached the stairs to exit the parking lot, he gave me a very nasty and cold stare and had the dog pointed in my direction, in a sense he made the dog come in my direction and sniff close to me. Now tell me that had nothing to do with the fact ke ghiyafam dad mizaneh irooni hastam. Its racial profiling, since if i was blond with blue eyes they man would have never done that. I was so tempted to talk back to him, but i was worried he would let the dog loose on me and I didnt want to be attacked by the dog.

                              no one has a perfect filter, but sometimes we need to acknowledge the fact that our filter may not work too well and we may be biased. I still cant understand why you would even for one second defend the cop, but i respect your ideas.
                              Mike the world we live in is not pretty. I know you would like to think that there is no black and white when it comes to gulity and not guilty, but normally there is no grey area either.
                              wow thats crazy what happend

                              but honestly you should expect some of that even thogh its wrong
                              becuase look many americans feel as if they were taken advantage of for being plurist.
                              best example they compare theme selfs with israel were over their they practice insane ratial profiling and they have a much better trak record of protecting everyone.
                              wiw reading the second post i can see what you mean with "new blacks"
                              i think your right but than right when i say that all the diffrent imagas of what they did to the blacks flashes in my head and it out ways whats happening tremandisly
                              can we say than on a micro level middle easterners are being treated unequaly.
                              see theirs the filter again
                              even thogh i thoght i experiance it i dont


                              G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                              Comment

                              • mike435
                                Senior Member
                                • Aug 2006
                                • 2104

                                #120
                                listen in my hearts of hearts i still dont belive they trageted him becuase he was middleeater
                                on what basis he might blow up the library
                                to take reveng on him becuase of current day stuff
                                i dout it man i really do

                                i know so many people who go theri all the time i am not a stufdent and i go their

                                shit i bet a huge percentage are persian in my sis's chem class almost the whole class is persian

                                i


                                G-d determines who walks into your life....It is up to you to decide who you let walk away, who you let stay, and who you refuse to let go.


                                Comment

                                Working...