UFO mind-melting in government report
Did you see these headlines this week? "Secret report says UFOs DO exist", screamed one. "UFOs don't exist, says MoD", said another. It turns out to have all stemmed from a 'secret report' by the UK's Ministry of Defence (MoD), which was unearthed by sleuthing academic David Clarke, a lecturer in investigative journalism at Sheffield Hallam University, UK. Clarke spent 18 months using the Freedom of Information Act to extract the report, authored in 2000, partly as a test-case exercise in exploiting the Act, he says. The main upshot of the report is that 'unidentified flying objects' technically do exist, but are mostly sightings of aircraft or odd weather phenomena. Fair enough.
But the media flurry over the report has struck me as at least a little odd. Many of them unquestioningly stated that MoD "scientists" have explained how balls of glowing plasma in the upper atmosphere could be mistaken for flying saucers, and that these plasma balls could in turn interfere with the brain, somehow conjuring up vivid abduction memories. This stems from a bit of the report's summary, which says: "Local fields of this type ... have been medically proven to cause responses in the temporal lobes of the human brain".So is this a solid, scientific explanation for UFO sightings? Sadly, no.
Did you see these headlines this week? "Secret report says UFOs DO exist", screamed one. "UFOs don't exist, says MoD", said another. It turns out to have all stemmed from a 'secret report' by the UK's Ministry of Defence (MoD), which was unearthed by sleuthing academic David Clarke, a lecturer in investigative journalism at Sheffield Hallam University, UK. Clarke spent 18 months using the Freedom of Information Act to extract the report, authored in 2000, partly as a test-case exercise in exploiting the Act, he says. The main upshot of the report is that 'unidentified flying objects' technically do exist, but are mostly sightings of aircraft or odd weather phenomena. Fair enough.
But the media flurry over the report has struck me as at least a little odd. Many of them unquestioningly stated that MoD "scientists" have explained how balls of glowing plasma in the upper atmosphere could be mistaken for flying saucers, and that these plasma balls could in turn interfere with the brain, somehow conjuring up vivid abduction memories. This stems from a bit of the report's summary, which says: "Local fields of this type ... have been medically proven to cause responses in the temporal lobes of the human brain".So is this a solid, scientific explanation for UFO sightings? Sadly, no.

Comment